MURDER, INC. EXCLUSIVE: Massapequa Park NYPD Sgt. WH is friends with filicide and alleged Satanic child sexual abuse and torture ring trafficker cop, NYPD’s Michael Valva
The first copper with the initials WH in the Massapequa Park phonebook is William Hughes. Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office planned to charge a cop, who lived within blocks of Rex Heuermann and has the initials WH, for the Gilgo Beach Murders. Bill Hughes lives only three blocks from Rex Heuermann in Massapequa Park and was an NYPD cop for 32 years. Seven of William Hughes siblings were police officers. Phil & Heather from Long Island first discovered the voice of a second female warning “you better hide, too” on the Shannan Gilbert 911 call. Murder, Inc. also hears this person saying something about a “cop” at the beginning of the tape. You need headphones (aka a magnifying glass) to hear this. The Suffolk County Police Department refused to let Shannan Gilbert’s family hear the 911 tape and claim that Shannan was not murdered.
It was reported back in 2011 that two NYPD coppers were suspects in the Long Island Serial Killer Murders. It makes sense now why the police would wait until after 2019 to release the WH belt used to bind Maureen Brainard-Barnes.
Sgt. William Hughes worked for the New York Police Department from 1987 to 2019 and received numerous complaints until he retired in 2019.
Rex Heuermann’s first cousin-once removed, Reverend Kenneth Heuermann aka Pastor Ken, allegedly ran a ritual child sexual abuse and pornography ring at his church in Camillus, NY.
On the night Shannan Gilbert called 911 asking them to save her from being murdered, she knocked on the door of Monsignor Alan Placa’s house.
Monsignor Alan Placa, who is Trump Party member Rudy Giuliani‘s lawyer and best friend, lived next door to Joe Brewer’s house, and is now being sued for drugging and raping kids. Placa is reported to have orchestrated the cover-up for the child sex trafficking ring run by the Catholic Church.
Monsignor Placa was investigated by a special grand jury led by Suffolk County District Attorney Thomas Spota. No charges were filed despite tons of children being raped by all the priests. Spota was in charge of the Gilgo Beach Murder investigation, had access to all the evidence, and the Suffolk County District Attorney now sits pretty in stir. The cops and G-Men had “the box” of the few blocks where Rex Heuermann and William Hughes lived in Massapequa Park by 2012, meaning all they had to do was drive around the block to see Rex Heuermann’s Chevy Avalanche parked out front.
The Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office was planning to charge WH as the Long Island Serial Killer, but Suffolk County Police Department Detectives obstructed the investigation until the DA’s Office changed their mind and decided to charge Rex Heuermann instead.
William Hughes appears to have attended Lynbrook Senior High School with Kelly Morrisey and lived near where she disappeared on June 12, 1984. Kelly Morrisey was friends with Theresa Fusco, who was also found murdered in Lynbrook in 1984. The Nassau County Police Department and Nassau County District Attorney’s Office intentionally framed three kids, John Kogut, John Restivo and Dennis Halstead, for Theresa Fusco’s murder. The police and DA lies were exposed and the three men were exonerated decades letter. William Hughes lived a few blocks from Kelly Morrisey’s disappearance and Theresa Fusco’s murder in 1984. William Hughes brother, Kevin Hughes, shows a possible address given for 1983- two doors from where Theresa Fusco lived on Windsor Place in Lynbrook when she was murdered. John Restivo, John Kogut and Dennis Halstead were all intentionally framed for murder by the Nassau County Police Department and Nassau County District Attorney’s with planted evidence.
On the afternoon of April 28, 2010, 38 year old Jennifer Poole was seen with two men in a yellow hummer outside her sister’s house in Central Islip. Jenny Poole asked to speak to her mother but was denied by her sister’s boyfriend, Neil, because Jenny was not supposed to be allowed in the house. But Poole introduced Neil to the men in the hummer, boxer Ernest “M-16” Mateen aka Champ and a man named Nacho in the back seat. Jenny had two black eyes, which, according to her, were caused by a picture frame falling onto her face. Neil asked Jenny if she was in trouble and needed help, but Jenny appeared to brush off his concerns and left.
According to the Suffolk County Police Department’s missing persons report for Jennifer Poole, she was last seen the next day on April 29, 2010 at her cottage on Mowbray Ave in Bay Shore, NY. Less than 48 hours later at 1:00 am on May 1, 2010, Shannan Gilbert left Manhattan and was driven by Michael Pak for an escort outcall to Joseph Brewer‘s house in Oak Beach, Babylon, NY.
From Joe Brewer’s home in Oak Beach, Shannan and Joe Brewer took a drive together to an unknown location and returned shortly thereafter. At 4:51 am, Shannan Gilbert called 911 begging for help because she was going to be murdered. A second woman can be heard warning “you better hide, too” at 0:30 on the recording of the 911 call. The 911 operator then asks Shannan “who’s there with you?” and Shannan says to the other girl “he’s coming”. Shannan Gilbert disappeared that night while on the phone with 911 and running through Oak Beach screaming and banging on the neighbors’ doors begging for help.
On May 3, 2010, Jennifer’s landlord went to Jenny’s sister Christine’s work and alerted her to the fact that Jenny was missing. He claimed he hadn’t seen Jennifer in a few weeks and asked if it was normal for her to disappear like this. Christine did indicate that her sister Jenny would go missing from time to time. Meanwhile, disgraced Suffolk County Police Surgeon Dr. Peter Hackett was calling Shannan Gilbert’s mother, asking if she knew Shannan was missing and telling her he ran a home for wayward girls.
On May 8, 2010, Christine Poole went to Jennifer Poole’s apartment and called the Suffolk County Police Department to report her sister missing. Eventually, a Suffolk County Police Department detective showed up and Christine Pool showed the detective blood spatter on the walls in the house, a piece of missing carpet and the strong smell of bleach. The detective warned Christine Pool not to touch anything and everything was off limits to her. In the possession of the Suffolk County Police Detective as evidence was a large garbage containing the bedding from Jennifer Poole’s bed.
On May 9, 2010 a detective from the Suffolk County Police Department called Christine Poole to inquire about her sister’s missing persons case. When Poole mentioned the blood splatter in the apartment, the Suffolk County Police Detective feigned ignorance and asked “what blood splatter?“
The next day, the Suffolk County Police Department dredged the canal behind the cottage where Jenny Poole lived. The crucial evidence of the bag containing the bedding that was in the possession of the Suffolk County Police Detective disappeared. The Suffolk County Police Department claimed to Poole’s family they are unable to trace where Jennifer Poole’s cellphone pinged before it was turned off.
Jennifer Poole lived in a rented cottage behind a home, like Murder, Inc.’s suspected Long Island Serial Killer victim Suzanne Goldfarb, who was found bound and strangled in her rented cottage in Merrick in 2015. And like Gilgo Beach Murder victim Amber Costello, Jenny Poole sometimes used $500 worth of recreational heroin a week. Amber and Jenny had both worked as escorts, they disappeared only 4 months apart, and lived less than six miles from each other!
Jennifer Poole is still missing. Shannan Gilbert’s body was later found in a marsh behind Oak Beach and along Ocean Parkway near the mass grave of 10+ victims of the Long Island Serial Killer. The Suffolk County Police Department fought the Shannan Gilbert Estate’s lawyer John Ray nearly to the death for the right to let Shannan’s Gilbert’s family hear here 911 Murder Call and refused to comply with court orders to release the tape for years.
On March 14, 2022, Long Island Serial Killer suspect Rex Heuermann was “first identified” as a man who was allegedly scammed at Amber Costello’s house on September 1, 2010 (multiple witnesses say Heuermann was not there). Two months later on May 13, 2022 the Suffolk County Police Department finally released Shannan Gilbert’s 911 call. In pure police fascion, SCPD cut out the beginning of the 911 call where a second girl can be heard saying “you better hide, too” from their press conference to cover up Shannan Gilbert’s murder. And they would have gotten away with it too, if it weren’t for Phil from Long Island and his wife Heather!
April 29 2010 Jennifer Poole Missing Bay Shore, NY Jennifer Poole lived in a cottage behind a home in Bay Shore, NY
Jennifer Poole disappeared after last being seen on April 29, 2010 at her apartment on Mowbray Ave in Bay Shore. Her apartment is only 6 miles from where Amber Costello lived, who was found murdered on Gilgo Beach.
May 1, 2010 Shannan Gilbert Missing Oak Beach, NY
In April 2011 it was reported that a second man was in Joe Brewer’s house with Shannan on the night she disappeared.
Joe Brewer’s house in Oak Beach where Shannan Gilbert was hired to go for an escorting outcall and Jennifer Poole’s cottage in Bay Shore were only 6 miles apart. Shannan and Jenny both had worked as escorts and disappeared within less than 48 hours of each other.
On May 3, 2010 Jennifer Poole’s landlord went to Christine Poole’s work to ask her about her missing sister. The same day, Dr. Peter Hackett called Shannan Gilbert’s mother Mari to claim Shannan had been at his “home for wayward girls.” Dr. Hackett publicly denied making the calls until telephone records proved he was lying.
On June 16, 2010, Newsday ran a story that the Suffolk County Police arrested five men who had gone to Jenny Poole’s cottage on an alleged fishing expedition were arrested for burglary. It’s unclear who the men were and what happened with their case.
Crime scene photos released by Discardedshow blood stains in Jennifer Poole’s cottage.
Discarded Podcast has been thoroughly investigating the disappearance of Jennifer Poole for years.
Murder, Inc. has long suspected a possible connection between the disappearances of Jennifer Poole and Shannan Gilbert because of the proximity in time and place in which the two went missing. Was Jennifer Poole at a party at Joe Brewer’s that night and is she the second girl on the 911 tape? If it’s not Jenny Poole, then who is it?
Official Full Shannan Gilbert 911 Murder Call
Congratulations to Phil from Long Island and his wife Heather for cracking the case!
Murder, Inc. Exclusive: Was 15 year old Tiffany Mason murdered by the Golden State Killer and left at his fishing hole in Lake Natoma in 2001?
On August 9, 2001 the nude body of a 15 year old girl from San Francisco named Tiffany Laverne Mason was fished out of Lake Natoma in Folsom, CA. She’d been bludgeoned with blows to the back of the head. Tiffany Mason had been sex trafficked by a pimp named Pairadice to a motel in Sacramento where she was last seen alive on August 4, 2001 and was believed to have been killed sometime between August 7 and August 8, 2001. “My boyfriend, Pairadice…“
Tiffany Mason disappeared from the National 9 Inn on Stockton Boulevard and Fowler Ave in Sacramento on August 4, 2001. The National 9 Inn on Stockton Boulevard in Sacramento where Tiffany Mason was last seen getting into the car of a man is less than a mile from the location of the May 28, 1977 East Area Rapist crime.
The San Francisco Examiner ran a series of in depth investigative reports by Adrienne Sanders on Tiffany Mason in May 2002 exposing the gross dereliction by the police that caused her murder. Two San Francisco Police Department detectives (Brian Philpott and Robert Porter) had found 15 year old Tiffany Mason nude and being sexually assaulted by a 49 year old man in a car. The SFPD detectives sent the man on his way with a ticket. In 1969 two SFPD cops (Donald Fouke and Eric Zelms) peeled up to the Zodiac, who was walking away from the Paul Stine murder in Presidio Heights and asked him which way the killer went.
Tiffany Mason was sex trafficked by her pimp Pairadice to adult male “regulars” at the Travel Lodge on Market Street and Valencia Street in San Francisco.
Pairadice trafficked Mason to a motel in Sacramento where she was last seen alive on August 4, 2001. Pairadice now goes by Uncle Damien and is a motivational speaker.
On October 27, 1970 the Zodiac mailed a Halloween card to Paul Avery at the San Francisco Chronicle. On the card was written the words Paradice Slaves.
On July 26, 1970, the Little List letter sent by the Zodiac arrived at the San Francisco Chronicle in which the writer spelled paradise as Paradice and described torturing his slaves in the afterlife.
Tiffany Mason was found nude and bludgeoned with blows to the back of the head. Joe DeAngelo’s “last known murder” was in 1986 when he bludgeoned a teenage Janelle Cruz to death by blows to the back of the head, in her home in Irvine, CA. The cops originally tried to frame someone else for the murder.
Jewell Sutton was raped and murdered in her home on Whittier Street in Exeter, CA in an area Joseph DeAngelo knew extremely well. After the discovery of the body, Tulare County Sheriff’s Detectives went to the home of an intellectually disabled man named David John Romero. Romero was taken in and questioned but denied involvement, he was driven home and then driven back again to the police station where a confession was extracted by the cops.
In court, Romero is described as nodding his head and smiling while looking at autopsy photos and trying to walk out of the court at the main exit with everyone else while his legs were shackled. Romero plead not guilty and later changed his plea to guilty to avoid the death penalty. Police love to frame and execute people with intellectual disabilities for murder. Exeter Police Sgt. rapist serial killer Joe DeAngelo’s family lived in Exeter when Jewell Sutton was murdered. The population of Exeter in 2001 was 9,264.
Tulare County Sheriff’s Detective Robin Skiles claimed David Romero admitted to murdering Jewell Sutton, then using the bathroom, drinking a 7-Up from the refrigerator and stealing jewelry from a dresser. David Romero plead guilty to avoid the death penalty. Early that year on January 10, 2001, a Happy New Year card was mailed to the San Francisco Examiner claiming to be from the Zodiac. The writer referenced the recent rash of pedestrians killed by San Francisco Municipal Railway Streetcars in San Francisco, made a racist remark and threatened to murder Muni drivers.
Is EXETcUTED a reference to Exeter, CA where San Francisco cab driving Zodiac victim Paul Stine had lived as a child and where Exeter Police Officer Serial Killer Cop Joe DeAngelo lived one house away from each other but 30 years apart?
On April 4, 2001 the news all over California, including the LA Times, reported that the East Area Rapist and Original Night Stalker were confirmed by DNA to be the same serial killer.
On April 5, 2001 the Sacramento Bee ran a story about the DNA link between the East Area Rapist and Original Night Stalker.
The next day or later that night on, April 6, 2001, a victim of the EAR received a taunting phone call from the killer.
On April 16, 2001 a home on Fithian Way in Folsom, CA was ransacked near where Tiffany Mason would be found murdered in Lake Natoma in August.
The Sacramento Bee ran a story on the front page about EAR/ONS on May 24, 2001. How was all the new coverage affecting the serial killer and his behavior?
At 5:00 am on June 29, 2001 the burned body of a young woman was found by firefighters in a dumpster on 18th Avenue near Power Inn Road in Sacramento. A 1970s orange Datsun 240Z or 260Z with a primer fender was seen near the fire in the dumpster where the body was found burned.
In 2019, the woman was identified by DNA as Perrean Gray, a 20 year old who had been reported missing from San Francisco. Perrean Gray was found murdered less than two miles from a 1977 East Area Rapist attack.
On July 23 2001 a prowler was reported on Austin Drive in Folsom after a woman returned home to see a man looking into her window from the backyard at 3:09 pm. Joseph DeAngelo is believed to have worked the overnight shift in 2001.
Two days after Tiffany Mason was found murdered in Lake Natoma on August 9, 2001, the body of Heidi Marie Bennett was found in the Sacramento River in Princeton, CA in August 11, 2001. Heidi Bennett had disappeared around July 20, 2001 from Marysville, CA. Page 32 of the August 17, 2001 Sacramento Bee features articles identifying both Tiffany Mason and Heidi Mendoza.
Heidi Bennett’s body was found in the Sacramento River north of Princeton, CA on August 11, 2001. Jewell Sutton was found murdered in Exeter the same day.
On September 19, 2001 a prowler was reported on Jasmine Court in Roseville. Joseph DeAngelo worked 1.75 miles north of the prowling at Roseville Savemart as a truck mechanic.
On September 21, 2001 a cat burglar broke into a Porterville home and stole jewelry, a fax machine and more while a woman slept. Cat burglars are rare and Porterville is just south of Exeter where DeAngelo was a cat burglar serial killer cop. This cat burglary was two miles east of a house DeAngelo worked on in Porterville in the 1980s.
On October 11, 2001, Miwok tribe member and activist Allan Olvera was found bludgeoned to death by blows to the head in the living room of his home in Sacramento. His house was ransacked and “Native American jewelry, electronics and personal items” were stolen and pottery was smashed. Personal photographs were either stolen or destroyed by the killer. Joseph DeAngelo would steal or destroy personal photos from his victims’ homes at crimes scenes. Allan Olvera’s killer stole or destroyed personal photographs, which was one telltale sign of an East Area Rapist crime scene. In November 2023 it was revealed that DNA and fingerprints were recovered from the Allen Olvera murder crime scene but Sacramento County was declining to prosecute. Could this be because Original Night Stalker policeman Joseph DeAngelo’s DNA and fingerprints were recovered from the Allan Olvera murder, but DeAngelo was given immunity from further prosecution in exchange for his guilty plea?
Allen Olvera was bludgeoned to death in his home on Turbo Court 5 miles straight south down Power Inn Road from where Perrean Gray was found murdered in June 2001. Allen Olvera was involved in the Nimbus Fish Hatchery at Lake Natoma.
On October 21, 2001 three kids playing behind an Arco gas station in Turlock, CA spotted a toe sticking out of the ground. The woman was later identified as Martina Polk, a 34 year old woman who was last seen on Mother’s Day, May 13, 2001. Turlock is halfway between Sacramento and Exeter, CA.
On December 3, 2001 93 year old Inez Kirsner was found murdered in her apartment on Julliard Drive in Sacramento. Her window was broken and her wheelchair and television stolen. Joseph DeAngelo, the Originial Night Stalker, left Manuela Witthuhn’s television in her backyard after he murdered her in 1981. Inez Kirsner was murdered in her home approximately 1.5 miles from where Perrean Gray was found murdered in June. Inez Kirsner or her family lived next to where suspected Golden State Killer Cop victim Phyllis Blasy had lived on Honeysuckle Way before moving to the home where she was murdered in Placerville 1978.
On February 10, 2002, 22 year old Heather Lee Ann Hibbs was found murdered in an irrigation canal in Vacaville, CA. She’d been bludgeoned to death by blows to the back of the head. Heather Hibbs was found bludgeoned to death in an irrigation canal in Vacaville. In 1974, Visalia teenager Jennifer Armour was found drowned in an Exeter canal after she’d been murdered by Exeter Police serial killer Joe DeAngelo. The police and district attorneys have covered up Joe DeAngelo’s involvement in her murder and were derelict in failing to obtain a confession by DeAngelo in her murder as part of his plea deal. Joseph DeAngelo worked for Savemart as a truck mechanic at their warehouse in Roseville but the Savemart distribution center was located in Vacaville.
Murder, Inc. Exclusive: Was Suzanne Goldfarb murdered by the Long Island Serial Killer in the bed of her Merrick, NY cottage in 2015?
On November 18, 2015 Suzanne Goldfarb, 48, was found murdered in the bedroom of her cottage in Merrick, NY. She’d been gagged and bound by her hands & feet and was discovered in her bed by her father who had stopped in to check on her. There were no signs of forced entry or robbery at the scene of the murder. Alleged Long Island Serial Killer suspect Rex Heuermann’s search history includes the term “bondage bed” along with other BDSM related terms. Suzanne Goldfarb was murdered by asphyxiation, reportedly caused by strangulation. The Gilgo Murder victims were also described as asphyxiated and are also suspected to have been strangled.
Alleged Gilgo Beach Killer Rex Heuermann‘s father, Theodore Heuermann, was from Merrick, only one mile from where Suzanne Goldfarb lived and was found murdered. Rex Heuermann’s cousin, Rev. Kenneth Heuermann, who allegedly ran a child sex abuse and torture ring, also grew up in Merrick, only two blocks from Rex’s father. One of the belts used to bind murder victim Maureen Brainard-Barnes found at the Long Island Serial Killer’s mass grave on Ocean Parkway was marked with the initials WH, theorized to stand for William Heuermann, Rex Heuermann’s grandfather. Are the bondage and location of Suzanne Goldfarb’s murder pathological clues that point to the Long Island Serial Killer?
Rex Heuermann’s father’s family, the Heuermanns, were long time residents of Merrick.
Rex’s father, Theodore was raised in Rex’s grandfather William Heuermann’s house at 14 Chapin Ave in Merrick, NY. Rex’s grandfather William Heuermann was the head custodian at North Merrick school for 18 years. Rex Heuermann’s father grew up only one mile north of the house where Suzanne Goldfarb was murdered.
Rex’s father Theodore Heuermann was reportedly known for jogging with a hatchet to fend off dogs and coyotes according to a neighbor quoted in the Daily News. The Times reported a neighbor of Rex Heuermann saying Rex frequently fought with his father before Theodore Heuermann died in 1975. Theodore Heuermann and his first cousins, Rev. Kenneth Heuermann and Nassau Police Lt. George Heuermann, grew up two blocks from each other in Merrick. Kenneth Heuermann and George Heuermann grew up in their father Alfred Heuermann’s home at 44 Maeder Ave in Merrick, NY.
Pastor Ken’s brother George Heuermann is seen in the photograph below giving a $100 check to the Boy Scouts of America on behalf of the Nassau County Police Department.
Rex Heuermann allegedly used the pseudonym “Andrew Roberts” and “Andy Roberts” online.
According to court documents, Rex Heuermann is alleged to have contacted an escort on March 4, 2020 and given his name as “Andy” and his email as Sandbagger303@gmail.com. The photograph used by the escort in the posting Rex Heuermann is alleged to have corresponded with appears to be fake.
Rex Heuermann allegedly used the email Sandbagger303@gmail.com to talk “bed info.”
A “sandbagger” is someone who gives fake reviews to an escort (according to Utopiaguide, the escort review forum)
A user named “Sandbagger” posted on the USAsexguide forum about a strip club in Greensboro, NC in 2016. Murder, Inc. previously reported that Rex Heuermann’s mother’s boyfriend died in Greensboro, NC. Sandbagger leaves numerous reviews in North Carolina and Virginia.
On December 23, 2015, one month after the Suzanne Goldfarb murder, Sandbagger posted about the Cup O’Jane in Raleigh, NC.
The Cup O’Jane in Raleigh, NC is just three miles from where Beth Ellen-Vinson was murdered in 1994 after meeting a client through an escort agency. A newspaper in Greensboro, NC received an anonymous letter claiming that Beth Ellen-Vinson was murdered because she was blackmailing a member of a sadomasochist group called “The Power Exchange of the Triangle.”
A user by the name of “Andy Roberts”, the same moniker allegedly used by Rex Heuermann, has been sandbagging or leaving fake reviews of escorts in NYC. Callescort.org user andy roberts’ reviews continue after July 13, 2023 when Rex Heuermann was arrested for the Gilgo Beach Murders meaning thisandy roberts account is not Rex Heuermann.
On June 21, 2007 users named hardrobert and jack sprat engaged in discussion about bondage and violent sexual assault posting on the Utopiaguide escort review forum. Two weeks later, Maureen Brainard-Barnes would be murdered by the Long Island Serial Killer. The user hardrobert, like andy roberts, appears to have been online after Heuermann’s arrest indicating this is also not Rex Heuermann. On May 27, 2002 jack sprat discussed the topic of Atlantic City sex work on Utopiaguide. Rex Heuermann’s family stayed in Atlantic City for two weeks in July 2007, just four miles from where Kim Raffo, Barbara Breidor, Tracy Roberts and Molly Dilts were found murdered in the weeds in November 2006 but police “ruled out” Rex Heuermann in the murders!
The proximity between the Flagship Resort in Atlantic City where Rex Heuermann’s credit card was used and the Atlantic City Serial Killer’s 2006 cluster site of four murdered women is only four miles.
On January 11, 2003 jack sprat posted the comment “kind of tough if we have to check out every asian male that has passed away” on the Utopiaguide forum. The last time jack sprat appears to have logged in on Utopiaguide was in 2013.
Jack Sprat is the title and subject of a well-known nursery rhyme and was a term used for people of small stature in the 16th century.
In a July 7, 2006 Utopiaguide post a user named rough1 describes hiring a sex worker for a BDSM torture session in what appears to have been a Manhattan hotel room. Rex Heuermann allegedly searched for the term “hanging by nipples”, rough1 mentions nipple clamps in his review on Utopiaguide. Rex Heuermann’s alleged search history terms paint a picture of a BDSM connoisseur decked out in a leather bondage suit with a suitcase full of torture gadgets, whips and canes. Ten days after Amber Costello disappeared, there was a BDSM Vendetta Party held in Bethpage just five miles from Rex Heuermann’s house in Massapequa Park, NY.
The Suffolk County Police Department and DA allege that Rex Heuermann is “the john” who texted Amber Costello on September 1, 2010 and September 2, 2010. They also allege that Rex Heuermann was at Amber Costello’s house on September 1, 2010 and again to pick her up on September 2, 2010 when she was last seen.
Witnesses and Amber Costello’s roommates Dave Schaller and Bear Brodsky say they remember encountering Rex Heuermann during a scam but it was not on September 1, the day before Amber disappeared. Dave Schaller identified the Chevy Avalanche as one driven by a john who they’d scammed for SCPD detectives in 2012 during a photo lineup, but the Suffolk County Police Department appear to have covered up the clue that would lead any idiot directly to the killer.
Murder, Inc. has considered the possibility that the burner phones and email logins listed in the court documents and allegedly used by Rex Heuermann could have been passed around and shared among fellow johns or members of a BDSM group like the Power Exchange of the Triangle. Swapping burner phones or email account logins with contact information for various sex workers could be one clandestine way for johns or group members to share information.
On July 14, 2010 a user named Morrie posted the comment “a friend of ours told me today that “You won’t hear from the 2 girls anymore!”” in response to a post about Amber Costello on the Long Island Erotic escort review forum. If Morrie was aware of Amber Costello’s murder a month and a half before it happened, the circumstances of Amber’s murder suggest a premeditated conspiracy.
Melissa Barthelemy’s voicemail was accessed from Freeport, which borders Merrick where Suzanne Goldfarb was murdered. Carmen Vargas was found murdered in Freeport in 1989 and according to Rex Heuermann’s wedding announcement he worked for the Greer Construction Corp. in Freeport in 1990.
Suzanne Goldfarb was found murdered less than a mile from where Carmen Vargas was found murdered in 1989. The house on Smith Street where Suzanne Goldfarb was found murdered is 6 miles west of Rex Heuermann’s home in Massapequa Park, NY.
According to court documents, the sadistic telephone calls made on August 5, 2009 from Melissa Barthelemy’s phone by the man believed to be the Long Island Serial Killer were triangulated to 245 W. 36th Street in New York, NY.
Two weeks after the August 5, 2009 taunting call made from Melissa Barthelemy’s phone and believed to be the Long Island Serial Killer that was triangulated to 245 W. 36th St, another call was made on August 19, 2009 and triangulated to 247 W. 36th St.
Located next door to 247 W. 36th Street is 255 W. 36th Street, address of the A.R.E.B.A-Casriel Institute Outpatient Substance Abuse Treatment Center run by none other than infamous Oak Beach resident and real-life Cruella de Vil, Steven Yohay!
Why was the caller, allegedly Rex Heuermann, making another call outside of or next door to Oak Beach resident Steven Yohay’s ACI Outpatient Rehab two weeks after the call on August 5, 2009?
Areba Casriel Institute Outpatient Services is located at 255 West 36th Street, 8th fl, New York, NY.
ACI Rehab was founded by Daniel Harold Casriel a proponent of primal scream and bonding psychotherapy who was Steven Yohay’s mentor.
ACI Founder Daniel Casriel’s therapeutic techniques included nude genital examination as part of ‘Encounter Group Therapy’ and “Bonding Theory”. Steven Yohay is mentioned in a Daily News article on the ACI drug rehab program from 1987 where he stated “there’s a lot of cocaine and dual addictions of drugs and alcohol among older executives.”
In 2020, Oak Beach resident Steven Yohay was implicated in an insurance fraud scheme where he employed drivers to procure at risk individuals who were Medicaid beneficiaries for his ACI substance abuse treatment centers.
The drivers employed by Steven Yohay were alleged to have used drugs to lure at-risk and homeless people to ACI Rehab. The scam was referred to as the Driver Kickback Covered Conduct in court documents.
Many of the patients in Yohay’s scam were New Jersey residents picked up in New Jersey and driven into Manhattan.
The A.R.E.B.A.-Casriel Institute has to pay a fine of $1,200,000 but Steven Yohay appears to have avoided any prison time.
Shannan Gilbert was driven by a driver named Michael Pak to conduct an outcall as an escort at 3:00 am at a residence in Oak Beach, NY. Michael Pak had served time in federal prison for a human trafficking related charge, conspiracy to misuse a passport. Steven Yohay/Stephen Yohay lived on Hawser Drive in Oak Beach, NY when Shannan disappeared. Her skeletal remains were found in the marsh near his home in December 2011.
Steven Yohay is also linked to a realty company called SJY Realty in Merrick, NY.
On February 1, 2005, a user named nyhotcpl posted on the Internationalsexguide forum claiming to be Steven Yohay. The post stated that the poster was Steven Yohay and they were staying in room 3106 at the Penininsula[sic] BKK in Bangkok. The user Sandbagger also posted on Internationalsexguide’s sister forum, USAsexguide. A user with the same username of nyhotcpl posted numerous swinger ads on a number of different hookup sites. nyhotcpl is about as common of a username as andy roberts and Murder, Inc. is unable to determine if any are the same poster from the nyhotcpl Internationalsexguide Bangkok post.
A user by the name of jackspratt also posted on the Thailand tourism forum Udonmap.com about a raid on a swingers club in Thailand. More posts from the same user nyhotcpl, who claimed to be Steven Yohay, appear on the International Sex Guide forum about Madrid in 2002 and Paris in 2003.
MURDER, INC. CRACK EXCLUSIVE: Gilgo Killer suspect Rex Heuermann’s cousin Rev. Kenneth Heuermann is a priest accused of leading a child sex abuse ring!!
In 1961, “RW”, an eight year old child, was dropped off to prepare for the Christmas pageant at St. Michael’s Lutheran Church in Camillus, NY. RW was chosen to star as Mary, mother of Jesus in the play and remembers being taken to the basement by a man in a gray suit, Edgar Rising. RW describes being left alone in a room to be undressed and sexually assaulted by Reverend Kenneth Heuermann. RW goes on to testify to years of repeated torture, ritual sexual abuse, and the making of child pornography by Pastor Ken Heuermann, Edgar Rising,Luther Myer and other men whom she did not know. Court documents obtained by Murder, Inc. allege years of ritual torture and child sexual abuse at the hands of Reverend Kenneth Heuermann.
Murder, Inc. is exclusively reporting that Rev. Heuermann, who is from Long Island, is alleged Gilgo Beach Killer suspect Rex Heuermann’s first cousin once removed. Rex Heuermann’s grandfather William Heuermann was brothers with Kenneth Heuermann’s father Alfred Heuermann. One of the three belts used to bind Gilgo Beach victim Maureen Brainard-Barnes was marked with the letters WH and it’s theorized to have belonged to Rex Heuermann’s grandfather and Kenneth Heuermann’s uncle, William Heuermann.
RW describes a fourth man who participated in the abuse but wore a police uniform or security guard uniform and was called “Mr. Roberts”. Reverend Kenneth Heuermann’s brother George Heuermann was the #2 cop in the Nassau County Police Department and attended the FBI academy in 1965. He’s seen below with #1 G-Man Edgar J. Hoover.
Over 11 bodies were found at the Long Island Serial Killer’s cluster site along Ocean Parkway, including one mother and child. Many of the LISK victims were under 5 feet tall and it’s been suggested they may have been surrogate victims chosen for their small stature in the place of children. Murder, Inc. also suspects the Long Island Serial Killer of more child murders besides the toddler found at Gilgo in the town of Babylon.
Rex Heuermann is alleged to have searched the internet for images of young girls crying. A girl from California claimed Rex flew her to NY and told her over pizza that his favorite serial killers were the Hillside Stranglers: Angelo Buono and his cousin Kenneth Bianchi. Rex Heuermann’s brother shows an address history in Bellingham, WA where Bianchi murdered two women in 1979.
RW reported her abuse to the Evangelical Lutheran Church and Bishop Perry in January 1991. In a photograph taken at St. Michael’s on September 8, 1991, Reverend Kenneth Heuermann is seen smiling and holding a balloon while leading a parade of children. The ritual torture and child sex abuse Rev. Kenneth Heuermann is accused of obviously raises deep and shocking questions about the psychopathological origins of the Long Island Serial Killer.
RW testified to first being assaulted by Reverend Kenneth Heuermann at St. Michael’s Lutheran Church when she was only 8 years old. RW testifies to being bound with clerical stoles and repeatedly tortured by Reverend Heuermann RW wrote Bishop Marie Jerge a letter in 2007 detailing her abuse at the church. Marie Jerge did nothing and tried to make the victim to meet with Kenneth Heuermann, the same man RW just told Marie Jerge had been raping her when she was child!
Reverend Kenneth Christian Heuermann grew up attending St. John’s Lutheran Church in Merrick, NY. He was part of the Luther League as a boy which he later was involved with in the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America.
Rev. Heuermann does not give Rex Heuermann’s name when listing his cousins.
Kenneth Heuermann’s brother George Heuermann was a big shot Nassau County Police Department cop who graduated from the FBI Academy and is seen pictured below with #1 G-Man Edgar J. Hoover.
Nassau County Police Officer and Rex Heuermann’s cousin George Heuermann is pictured here with President Dwight D. Eisenhower in 1953.
RW describes a man called “Mr. Roberts” who wore a police uniform and was part of the child abuse ring.
RW recounted to her therapist memories of abuse involving a cop
Rex Heuermann’s grandfather William Heuermann and Kenneth Heuermann’s father Alfred Heuermann were brothers. One of the belts used to bind LISK victim Maureen Brainard-Barnes was initialed with the letters WH and is suspected to have belonged to Rex Heuermann’s grandfather, William Heuermann.
The cops hid the images of the belt from the public for ten years while the Long Island Serial Killer was free to murder at will. The Suffolk County Police Department also had the information identifying Rex Heuermann for over ten years but incredulously claim to have “forgotten” to investigate the witness Dave Schaller’s tip. Schaller was the roommate of last known LISK victim, Amber Costello and the last to see her alive.
On June 14 1959 Reverend Kenneth Heuermann was moved to St. Michael’s Lutheran Church in Camillus, NY where he worked for the next 30 years.
Reverend Kenneth Heuermann claims he’s a 92 year old virgin. Kenneth Heuermann lived at the church parsonage for many years and RW testifies to being brought to his house and raped.
RW describes Kenneth Heuermann as a tall man, at least 6 ft 2 inches and usually outfitted in black clerical garb.
Rev. Heuermann acknowledges the children of the church were dressed in ritual garments called albs.
RW describes Kenneth Heuermann and Edgar Rising using purple stoles to bind and torture her in her testimony.
RW testifies to Kenneth Heuermann and Edgar Rising taking photographs of themselves torturing and assaulting her as a child.
RW asked for help from a church leader named Elizabeth Rising in St. Michael’s Lutheran Church. Elizabeth Rising, who RW says saw her being abused, refused to help the child and let the priest and other men rape her. She was the loving wife of Edgar Rising. Betty J. Rising’s obituary describes her as “a woman of strong faith”. Kenneth Heuermann was part of the Luther League Youth Group as a boy growing up on Long Island.
RW repeatedly told the Evangelical Lutheran Church for decades that Reverend Heuermann and the other church members had assaulted her at St. Michael’s Lutheran Church as a child but they did nothing about the abuse and instead told the victim she needed to confront the abuser if she wanted them to take any action.
On August 13, 1967 Mary Ann Marzullo & Jacqueline Saunders were found murdered in a remote field in Cicero, NY. The two 14 year old girls were bound together and strangled to death. The rope that bound them together also bound the girls’ hands behind their backs. Because the two girls were bound together some suspected more than one killer was involved. The victims were tortured before their murder and with bruises on their faces and bodies. The two 14 year old girls were found bound together and strangled near a creek in Cicero in 1967. RW describes being kidnapped and taken to a creek in the woods on Warners Road where she was raped by Reverend Kenneth Heuermann and Edgar Rising around this time. St. Michael’s Lutheran Church is 16 miles from where Marzullo and Saunders were found murdered. Witness described a black and/or blue 1959 or 1960 sedan seen near the crime scene.
In the 1960s Rev. Kenneth Heuermann drove a two tone blue Chevy Impala sedan.
One month later on September 25, 1967 17 year old Rose Ann Spina was found raped and strangled in the weeds of a lot in Syracuse. Was her murder connected to the recent Marzullo & Saunders case?
September 25 1967 Rose Spina Murder Syracuse, NY
Rev. Kenneth Heuermann (accused of raping and torturing children) was also on the Board of Education for the West Genesee Central School District.
In 1991 RW alerted Bishop Edward K. Perry to her abuse by Kenneth Heuermann. Betty Rising sat outside the room during RWs meeting with Bishop Perry. Bishop Reverend Dr. Edward Kersten Perry apparently did nothing and had worked at Parkside Lutheran in Buffalo in the 1950s like Rev. Heuermann.
RW alerted the Evangelical Lutheran Church and it’s Bishop Edward K. Perry to her child abuse in JANUARY 1991. Reverend Kenneth Heuermann is seen in a photo parading with children in ritual albs in September 1991, eight months after RW reported him to the bishop and District Attorney.
RW also alerted the District Attorney who did absolutely nothing.
In 1993, a Lutheran Reverend named Rev. George Mather founded the New England Institute of Religious Research as a “counter-cult ministry” that preaches about the dangers of Satanic cults while his fellow Christian priests perpetuate widespread sexual abuse against children. Rev. Mather, a consultant to the G-Men was involved in investigating the New Bedford Highway Murders in Massachusetts long suspected of being connected to the Long Island Serial Killer murders.
The Upstate New York Synod Evangelical Lutheran Church office headquarters is at St. Michael’s Lutheran Church in Camillus where Rev. Kenneth C. Heuermann lived and was the priest for decades. The head of Upstate NY Synod of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America from 2002-2014 was Marie Jerge, who is from Babylon, NY. RW asked Bishop Marie Jerge for help in 2007 about Reverend Heuermann’s abuse but Jerge tried to force the RW to meet with the man she said had repeatedly tortured sexually abused her. Bishop Jerge had Rev. Heuermann, accused of raping and torturing children in the congregation where Jerge worked, “promise that he would not.” ?! Bishop Marie Jerge had known accused child rapist Rev. Kenneth Heuermann since 1978. Babylon native Bishop Marie Jerge’s office was located at St. Michael’s Lutheran Church in Camillus, NY where Kenneth Heuermann lived and worked with unfettered access to children for many, many years. Marie Jerge found Ken Heuermann to be no threat to children. Marie Jerge admitted she was trained in how to spot victims of child abuse. Jerge appears to have worked at the office St. Michael’s Lutheran Church and met with RW and her therapist there where RW was abused.
In 2014 John Macholz replaced Marie Jerge as head bishop of the Upstate NY Synod of the ELCA. John Macholz is from Islip, NY on Long Island.
Bishop John Macholz testified he didn’t know the status in the church of accused child rapist Reverend Kenneth Heuermann.
Reverend Kenneth Heuermann testified that even after he was accused of child sexual abuse he was welcomed and embraced by the Lutheran Church
July 18 2019 Reverend Kenneth Heuermann Anniversary Celebration Camillus, NY
Rev. Heuermann was one of a never-ending list of priests and pastors accused of abusing children. An article in the Buffalo News on December 23, 2019 details a lawsuit accusing Rev. Bruce Connolly of the abuse during his time at First Trinity Lutheran Church in Tonawanda. The details and coverup by the Lutheran Church read almost exactly like the details in the Kenneth Heuermann abuse case.
In November 2019 the Pastor of St. Michael’s Lutheran Church, Paul Dreher-Wiberg gave this message about the lawsuit against his church for raping and torturing children. Reverend Heuermann, who is accused of raping children in the church is still listed on the church bulletin this message appeared in as Pastor Emeritus:
September 2022 Pastor Emeritus Kenneth Heuermann St. Michael’s Lutheran Church Camillus, NY
RW describes a hymn that Pastor Ken Heuermann would sing with the words “it is truly right and solitary” during her abuse.
This is from the Lutheran Preface hymn with the lyrics “it is truly meet, right, and salutary.”
RW describes how a boy named Olin Smith who tried to help her as a child may remember the abuse. RW wrote Olin Smith but never heard back.
Reverend Heuermann gives short and concise answers during his entire deposition, until he’s asked about RW. Suddenly, Kenneth Heuermann asks if he can “tell a little story?”. Heuermann then claims he just happened to be looking at a photo of RW’s confirmation class with, who would you guess but Olin Smith, when Smith pointed to RW in the photo and said “I couldn’t think of a thing about her.”
RW suffers from Dissociative Identity Disorder due to the extreme trauma she experienced when she was young.
In 2008 a post on the now defunct bygoneli.com forum describes a strange encounter in the woods of Manorville near the Long Island Serial Killer’s cluster site. A group of friends off-roading observed a long row of cars parked deep in the woods at the end of a trail. They then stumbled upon group of men in black clothing in a huddle who appeared to be doing something with rocks that were painted red and numbered. Some rocks appeared to have the #20 written on them and another the #30. An empty large bucket was near the cars.
RW describes Rev. Kenneth Heuermann using stones with either writing on them or arranged to spell her name as part of a ritual to sexual assault her that took place near a creek on Warners Road:
When asked if he ever touched RW, Reverend Kenneth Heuermann’s response was “Never. Never. Never. Never. Never. Never. Never.”
MURDER, INC. EXCLUSIVE: Ann Rippel was found murdered and bound around the neck with duct tape in a creek 8 miles from where Rex Heuermann’s uncle lived in rural Upstate NY!
On April 23, 1997 the body of Annie Rippel Lee was discovered in Little Tonawanda Creek in Alexander, NY. She was found nude from the waist down and her clothes were scattered around the creek. Her neck and mouth area were bound with duct tape, just like the Long Island Serial Killer Gilgo 4 victims. Annie Rippel was last seen at 11 pm the night before outside her home at 511 East Main Street in Batavia, NY. In 2007, Rex Heuermann’s uncle Valentine Socha died at the Veterans Home in Batavia, NY. Valentine Socha lived on Creek Road in Pavilion, NY. Annie Rippel was found murdered only 8 miles straight west from Rex Heuermann’s uncle’s house. DNA was recovered from the Annie Rippel Lee crime scene that can be compared to Rex Heuermann. G-Men and cops, please do so immediately at the request of Murder, Incorporated.
On September 26, 2021 the skeletal remains of a woman in a shallow grave were located in a remote wooded area off Woleben Road in Portland, NY. The next day the skeletal remains of a second woman were recovered in the same location only ten yards away. She was later identified as Marquita Mull from Buffalo, NY who had disappeared in June 2021. The first set of remains have not been identified and are of a woman believed to have been killed in the 1990s.
The fact that both victims were hidden so close together in the same remote location is an extremely strong indicator a serial killer who has been active for decades is responsible. The killer returned to the same location and the victims were hidden at a cluster site many years apart, just like the 10+ Long Island Serial Killer victims hidden along Ocean Parkway. Because alleged Long Island Serial Killer suspect Rex Heuermann has family who live in Upstate New York and because Rex Heuermann is known to have frequently traveled to Upstate NY he is a prime suspect in these murders and needs to be eliminated as the killer.
On October 29, 1983 hunters found the badly decomposed body of a woman in the woods in the Iroquois National Wildlife Refuge in Shelby, NY. In 2014 the woman was identified as Shari Lynne Ball, who disappeared from Florida in June 1983. She is suspected to be a victim of serial killer Christopher Wilder.
November 4, 1983 Bessie Williams disappeared from Endicott, NY. Her skeletal remains were found in a wooded area of King Street in Barker, NY. A man was seen driving a small white car in the area where Williams’ remains were found around the time she disappeared. The man was described as 25-30 years old, intoxicated, medium to large build, pot-bellied with brown disheveled hair wearing a blue windbreaker, blue jeans, brown work boots. Some reports indicate the man’s height as between 5’7 and 5’9 and others as 6 feet tall. The car being driven was possibly a white 1979 Ford Fiesta or a Chevy Chevette. Rex Heuermann’s sister lived in Chenango Forks just 8 miles from where Bessie Williams was found murdered. It’s unclear at this time if Heuermann’s relatives were living in the area or if Heuermann frequented there as far back as 1983.
On July 14, 1984 the dismembered torso of a woman was found floating in Lake Ontario in Oswego, NY. In 2012 she was identified as 14 year old Nancy Jo Scamurra, who disappeared only two weeks earlier on July 1, 1984 from Amherst, NY over 160 miles from where her torso was found.
On August 19, 1989 the nude body of Deanna Willener was found on a strip of land along the Allegheny River in Allegany, NY by fishermen. She’d been shot twice in the back of the head with a small caliber firearm and had disappeared from Franklin, OH on July 31, 1989. Rex Heuermann’s relatives resided in Ohio.
On August 27, 1989 the body of 27 year old Jacqueline Dicker was found along Interstate 490 and Route 204 in Rochester, NY. She was found with a trash bag over her head, was bound and had been strangled with a cord.
After serial killer Arthur Shawcross was arrested in Rochester in January of 1990, a completely forgotten serial killer The Rochester Serial Killer, continued to murder 18+ women over the next three years.
On April 27, 1990 the body of Patricia Grimes was found face down in a ditch on Chase Road off Lake Ontario State Parkway in Hamlin, NY. She was nude and her face was bloodied. Grimes had been strangled with an electrical cord. She was the first known victim found at the Rochester Serial Killer’s cluster site in the weeds and wooded areas along Lake Ontario State Parkway around Hamlin, NY where the remains of at least 5 Rochester woman would be discovered over the next two years.
On October 8, 1990 Judith McElheney was found nude from the waist up after being shot in the head along Route 5 in Sheridan, NY. McElheney was apparently able to give some info to police about her killer but died shortly after. Judy McElheney was from Buffalo, NY and lived in the area where Marquita Mull is believed to have disappeared from.
On December 13, 1990 Rebecca Nicholson was found shot to death in her home on Prospect Road in Westfield, NY. Nicholson was shot once through the heart with a small caliber weapon. Her home on Prospect Road is only three miles from where the skeletal remains of two women were found hidden at the same spot in the woods in 2021 on Woleben Road in Portland, NY. One of the woman is believed to have been killed in the early 1990s placing her murder around the time of Rebecca Nicholson’s, indicating the same serial killer could be responsible for all three murders.
On December 31, 1990 Moraine Armstrong was found bound and strangled to death with electrical cords in her Rochester apartment. In 2006, Robert Spahalski confessed to her murder. It’s unclear if he is a suspect in all the Rochester Serial Killer murders or if he has been eliminated. The cops and G-Men seem more interested in covering up these murders than solving them, which is probably why you’ve never heard of the unsolved case or any of the 18 women murdered.
On May 17 1991 the partially clothed body of Kasandra Carlton was found murdered on Ferrano Street in Rochester. She’d been strangled with a cord that was still around her neck. One of Carlton’s hands was badly burned. Two months later on July 10, 1991 the body of Katrina Myers was found murdered on an embankment near the railroad tracks on Ferrano Street only 250 yards from where Kasandra Carlton’s body had been found. Myers was found nude with a plastic grocery bag over her heard and like Carlton, had been strangled.
On October 13, 1991 the badly decomposed nude body of 31 year old Renita Rembert was found in a wooded near railroad tracks by a recycling center on Cairn Street in Rochester, NY. One month later on November 2, 1991 the body of Laverne Hughes was found murdered in the woods near the Durand Eastman Golf Course in Rochester. She’d been strangled to death with a cord.
On January 2, 1992 the body of Deborah Woodard was found murdered in a dumpster behind a building in Rochester, NY. She was killed by asphyxiation and had been strangled.
Alenda Height was found murdered on May 17, 1992 in Honeoye Creek in Rush, NY. Height was found nude and had been strangled. Her breasts had been mutilated by her killer. Height was found murdered 17 miles from where Rex Heuermann’s uncle lived in Pavilion, NY.
On September 2, 1992 Glenda Crittenden was found murdered in the weeds near the beach off Lake Ontario State Parkway on Lake Ontario in Parma, NY. The location where Glenda Crittenden was found is similar to Ocean Parkway on Long Island where the Long Island Serial Killer victims were dumped in the brush and weeds on a parkway along the beach and next to a large body of water. Crittenden had disappeared from Rochester, NY. On October 10, 1992 kids found Cindy Thiele’s skeletal remains in the brush and trees along Lake Ontario State Parkway in Hamlin, NY. Thiele’s skeletal remains were the third set of remains located at the Rochester Serial Killer’s Lake Ontario State Parkway cluster site. Cindy Thiele had disappeared from Rochester in July 1992.
A few weeks later on October 25, 1992 the body of Betty Gaddy was found at the Rochester Serial Killer’s Lake Ontario State Parkway cluster site in Hamlin, NY. She was the fourth Rochester woman to be found murdered and left in the weeds along the side off the same 3 mile stretch of parkway.
Sandra Johnson was found murdered on Lake Ontario State Parkway on November 2, 1992 just a few hundred feet from where Betty Gaddy was found murdered one week earlier. She was the fifth and last known victim found at the Rochester Serial Killer’s Lake Ontario State Parkway cluster site. The killer’s behavior shows many similarities with the Long Island Serial Killer. The victims were dumped in the weeds and clustered along a state parkway next to beach and a large body of water. The victims all disappeared from Rochester and most were believed to have been involved in sex work. The Lake Ontario State Parkway cluster site is 30 miles from where Rex Heuermann’s uncle lived in Pavilion, NY. On December 7 1991 Victoria Jobson was found murdered and left in a vacant lot in Rochester, NY. She’d been stabbed to death and is considered the 15th victim of the Rochester Serial Killer.
Seven days later on January 27, 1993 the skeletal remains of Janine Clausen were found in a remote section of woods along Jones Bridge Road in Leicester, NY. Janine Clausen is considered the 16th victim of the Rochester Serial Killer and was found murdered in the woods only 16 miles from Rex Heuermann’s uncle’s house in Pavilion, NY. This leads Murder, Inc. to suspect the Rochester Serial Killer and the Long Island Serial Killer may in fact be the same serial killer.
On August 18 1993 Natalie Rippe was found murdered in a vacant apartment in Rochester, NY. Rippe was found bound and partially clothed and was the 18th victim of the Rochester Serial Killer.
On December 16 1993 the nude body of Shamon Smith was found face down in a pile of leaves behind a house at 635 West Main Street in Rochester, NY. She’d been shot with a shotgun in the chest and was possibly beaten in the face.
On June 17, 1994 the partially nude body of Jandell Broadnax was found covered with a sheet at the Greyhound bus station on Central Ave in Rochester, NY. Broadnax had been asphyxiated.
A man named John White was suspected by police of being the Rochester Serial Killer but White died in 1994. The 18+ victims of the Rochester Serial Killer and the abhorrent violence the killer wreaked upon the area is sadly long forgotten with what appears to be only one obscure mention on the entire internet. Was Rex Heuermann frequenting Rochester enough between 1990 and 1994 to be the Rochester Serial Killer?
On April 2, 1995 the torso of a woman wearing a black bra was found on the shore of Lake Ontario behind a home. She has never been identified.
On April 23 1997 Annie Rippel Lee was found face down in Little Tonawanda Creek in Alexander, NY. Rippel was nude from the waist down and her clothes were scattered around. Rippel’s neck and mouth were bound with duct tape like Long Island Serial Killer victims found at Gilgo Beach. Annie Rippel disappeared from Batavia, NY and her sister had no idea why she would be in Alexander. In 2007, Rex Heuermann’s uncle Valentine Socha died at the Veterans Home in Batavia, NY. Rex Heuermann’s uncle lived only 8 miles straight east from where Ann Rippel Lee was found murdered.
On June 7, 1997 Lori Ceci Bova disappeared after leaving her home in Jamestown, NY. Her husband told police they’d had an argument and she was never seen again.
On July 1, 1997 Benjamin Gonzalez-Reyes, 20, was found shot to death off the Eastside Overland Trail off Bard Road in Arkwright, NY.
On September 23, 2000 the badly decomposed body of Jacqueline McCalop, 43, was found by duck hunters at a boat launch along the Hudson River in Greenport, NY. McCalop had disappeared from Catskill, NY where she lived. She had been stabbed several times.
On August 20, 2002 Regina Parmer disappeared from Niagra Falls, NY where she lived and worked as a nurse. Her badly decomposed remains were found on November 9, 2002 50 miles east in a remote section at the end of Lake Ontario State Parkway in Carlton, NY 17 miles west of the Rochester Serial Killer’s known cluster site.
On August 29, 2002 the badly decomposed body of a pregnant woman who had been murdered was found wrapped in a tan plastic shower curtain near a remote fishing access road in Wolcott, NY. She remains unidentified. The woman was seven months pregnant when she was murdered.
On October 4, 2002 Kisha Sullivan disappeared while walking to a convenience store in Rochester, NY. Kisha Sullivan was deaf and 27 year old. Her partially decomposed remains were found in a wooded area near a quarry on October 27, 2002 in Le Roy, NY approximately 20 miles from where she disappeared. She’d been murdered by blunt force trauma to to the head. Rex Heuermann’s uncle lived only 6 miles from the spot where Kisha Sullivan was found murdered.
On October 21, 2002 the body of Jeannine Cassidy was found in a creek in Perinton two miles from where Sharon Shechter disappeared. Police said her death was suspicious but thought it appeared accidental.
On August 10, 2004 Yolanda Bindics disappeared after leaving the store where she worked in Jamestown, NY. Her skeletal remains were discovered on September 10, 2006 in the woods along the Earl O. Cardot Eastside Overland Trail in Charlotte, NY. Benjamin Gonzalez-Reyes was found murdered on this same remote trail in 1997.
On June 23, 2005 Christina White disappeared after leaving the mobile home park where she lived in Ballston Spa less than a mile from where Jennifer Hammond disappeared in 2003. Her skeletal remains were found in the woods in Greenfield, NY on March 10, 2006 less than two miles from where Jennifer Hammond’s skull would be found in 2009. Both girls disappeared from mobile home parks in Ballston Spa.
On January 11 2006 Bambi Lynn Madden disappeared after leaving to walk to a deli from her home at 29 Winding Way in Binghampton, NY and was never seen again.
On May 20, 2006 the torso of a woman was recovered from Devil’s Hole State Park on the Niagra River in Lewiston, NY.
On June 1, 2006 Penny Schicker was found shot to death in Williamson, NY. Schicker lived a few blocks from Kisha Sullivan in Rochester.
Traci Douglass disappeared in January of February of 2007 from Salamanca, NY. Her skeletal remains were located along the Allegheny Reservoir in South Valley, NY in September 2009.
Long Island Serial Killer suspect Rex Heuermann’s brother-in-law lived in Schenectady, NY and shows two residences during the time period the murder took place less than a mile from the group home where Denise Hart was last seen.
Bethany Dougherty was last seen in her house in Killawog at 10 pm by her son on April 1, 2008. At 3 am a neighbor called 911 after hearing a woman screaming. The cops showed up, did nothing, left, and Bethany Dougherty was never seen again. A mid or late 90s Chevy S-10 truck was seen in the vicinity around the time of her disappearance. The late 90s Chevy S-10 looks similar to the Chevy Avalanche models owned by Rex Heuermann.
In the worst crime fighting job of all time, the incompetent G-Men and cartoonishly corrupt Suffolk County Police Department both hilariously failed to perform a proper search in the vehicle database for the alleged Long Island Serial Killer’s vehicle, a first generation Chevy Avalanche. This dereliction of duty allowed the serial killer to potentially murder with impunity for the next 13 years. The G-Men and cops are responsible and must be held accountable for the deaths committed after Rex Heuermann’s description and Chevy Avalanche was given to them by the last known LISK victim’s roommate.
Corrie Anderson disappeared after leaving a car dealership on October 28, 2008 in Jamestown, NY and was never seen again. Anderson disappeared less than a mile from where Yolanda Bindics disappeared in 2004. She disappeared approximately 1.5 miles from where Kathy Wilson lived in 1988 and 2 miles from where Melanie Juul was found shot to death outside the home for people with disabilities where she worked after walking to a deli in 1993.
On March 22, 2009 Keisha Roman disappeared on Oak Street in Binghamton approximately one block from where Bambi Madden vanished in 2006. On September 21, 2009 her remains were found at a boat launch along the Susquehanna River in Great Bend, PA. Five days later the skeletal remains of Traci Douglass were found along the Allegheny Reservoir in South Valley, NY over 150 miles away.
In 2008 the NYPD arrested, charged and likely caged Melissa Barthelemy for “suspicion of prostitution” on the street, destroying her future opportunities and forcing her directly on to the path that led to her violent murder at the hands of sadistic predators who prey on these woman the cops treat like bird feed.
On August 1, 2010 the body of Rosita Sanders was found in the Genesee River in Rochester. Cops believe she was murdered and put into the river on July 25, 2010. Long Island Serial Killer victim Amber Costello found at Gilgo Beach disappeared one month later on September 2, 2010.
On September 22, 2010 the body of Jaklyn Baccoli was found hidden in an abandoned house on Walnut Street in Rochester that was set to be demolished. Baccoli, a 44 year old Rochester resident had been raped and murdered.
On August 29, 2012 the dismembered torso of Loretta Gates was found in the water at Niagra Falls. On September 9, 2012 her head and arm were discovered in a bag floating on Hyde Park Lake near Duck Island in Niagra Falls, NY. 30 year old Niagra Falls resident Loretta Gates had disappeared after walking from her mother’s house to the convenience store on August 25, 2012.
On December 17, 2015 the skeletal remains of an unidentified woman were found in Ephrata, NY.
On April 8, 2016 Brenda Halpin disappeared from her home in Chenango Bridge, NY. Halpin lived two miles from Rex Heuermann’s sister in Chenango Forks, NY. Brenda Halpin was found drowned in the Chenango River in Binghamton, NY.
On August 8, 2017 Nicole Marranca disappeared from the Meadow Court Inn in Ithaca, NY and was never seen again.
On April 21, 2018 the body of Brian Heyden was discovered murdered in a wooded area near the town park along Route 20 in Portland, NY. Heyden had received a ride from a man in a white truck on the day before he was found murdered. Heyden’s body was discovered at the entrance to the Chautauqua Rails to Trails.
On June 30, 2018 Melody Lebowitz was found murdered in her Jamestown, NY basement apartment. She was killed by blunt force trauma to the head. Cops appear to be covering up her murder.
On September 26, 2021 the skeletal remains of an unidentified woman were found in a shallow 6 inch grave in the woods on Woleben Road in Portland, NY near the Chautauqua Rails to Trails. The woman is believed to have been murdered in the early 90s and remains unidentified. She is described by cops as between 15-35 and 4’11-5’7. The next day the skeletal remains of a second woman were discovered in the same spot only a few feet away! The woman was later identified as Marquita Mull, a 50 year old woman who vanished from Buffalo on June 25, 2021.
One key clue to the Long Island Serial Killer is the fact the victims are dumped in clusters at the same location over the span of decades. Jane Doe and Marquita Mull being dumped in a cluster in the same exact remote wooded spot potentially 28 years apart indicates a serial killer who has been active for a long time.
On October 17, 2022 the remains of Clarence Kewalski were located in a wooded area off Wick Street in Jamestown, NY. He was last seen after leaving a rehab in Saratoga Springs, NY north of Albany over 300 miles across the state. Only a week later on October 25, 2022 the body of a male was found in a wooded field behind homes on Wick Street in Buffalo, NY. The male is described as white, approximately 40s, 6 ft with a Yinyang tattoo on their wrist. A bedsheet is listed as being recovered with the man’s body, which most likely means he was found wrapped in the bedsheet. In 2012, an unidentified man’s body was found wrapped in a bed sheet along with 4 other Long Island Serial Killer victims at LISK’s Manorville cluster dump site around the Long Island Expressway in Manorville.
On May 22, 2023 the remains of a woman were discovered hidden in a wooded area near pumping station along the Susquehanna River in Binghamton, NY at the same spot where James Schaefer’s body was discovered in 2010. The location is approximately 9 miles from Rex Heuermann’s sister’s house.
According to Rex Heuermann, he traveled to visit his sister in Binghamton, NY
October 29 1983 Shari Lynne Ball Murder Shelby, NY
November 4 1983 Bessie P. Williams Missing Endicott, NY Bessie Williams disappeared from Johnson City near Binghamton, ten miles from where Rex Heuermann’s sister lives
December 6 1983 Ellery Doe Murder Ellery, NY
July 14 1984 Nancy Jo Scamurra Murder Lake Ontario, NY Nancy Scamurra was found murdered and dismembered in Lake Ontario in Oswego, NY over 150 miles from where she disappeared in Amherst near Buffalo. She was only 14 years old. It took cops 30 years to identify her and they never found her killer.
April 11 1985 Bessie P. Williams Murder Barker, NY Bessie Williams was found murdered in the woods approximately 8 miles from where Rex Heuermann’s sister lived in Chenango Forks, NY
July 1987 Sharon Pulaski Missing Alden, NY Sharon Pulaski disappeared after going to the store in Alden, NY approximately 3 miles from where Kisha Stanley was found murdered in a creek in 2001
December 11 1987 Sharon Eady Murder Rochester, NY Sharon Eady was found murdered in a wooded area behind a vacant house in Rochester near where Renita Rembert was later found murdered by the Rochester Serial Killer
August 17 1989 Deanna Sue Willener Murder Allegany, NY
August 27 1989 Jacqueline Dicker Murder Gates, NY Jacqueline Dicker is one of the first possible victims of The Rochester Serial Killer
September 24 1989 Kathy Wilson Murder Warren, PA
April 27 1990 Patricia Grimes Murder Hamlin, NY Patricia Grimes was the first known victim found at the Rochester Serial Killer’s Lake Ontario State Parkway cluster site in Hamlin, NY
October 8 1990 Judy McElheney Murder Sheridan, NY Judy lived near the Broadway-Fillmore area of Buffalo where Marquita Mull disappeared from 2021 before she was found murdered at what appears to be a serial killer’s cluster site in Portland, NY. Judy McElheney was found murdered 15 miles from Marquita Mull and the unidentified woman
December 13 1990 Rebecca Nicholson Murder Westfield, NY
Rebecca Nicholson was found shot to death in her home on Prospect Road in Westfield, NY only 3 miles from where the skeletal remains of two women would be found hidden in the woods a few feet from each other in 2021. One of the victims was murdered in 2021, the other victims death is believed to date back to the early 90s around the time Nicholson was killed, suggesting the same serial killer may have been active in the area and responsible.
May 17 1991 Kasandra Carlton Murder Ferrano Street Rochester, NY
July 10 1991 Katrina Myers Murder Ferrano Street Rochester, NY Katrina Myers and Kasandra Carlton were found murdered and hidden at the same location a few months apart
October 13 1991 Renita Rembert Murder Rochester, NY
November 2 1991 Laverne Hughes Murder Rochester, NY
January 2 1992 Deborah Ann Woodard Murder Rochester, NY
May 17 1992 Alenda Height Murder Honeoye Creek Rush, NY Alenda Height and Rinita Rembert lived behind each other in Rochester, NY
Alenda Height was found murdered in Honeoye Creek in Rush, NY. Alenda Height was found murdered 17 miles from Rex Heuermann’s uncle’s house in Pavilion, NY.
September 2 1992 Glenda Crittenden Murder Lake Ontario State Parkway Parma, NY
Glenda Crittenden was found murdered and dumped along the Lake Ontario State Parkway near where Patricia Grimes was found in 1990.
October 10 1992 Cindy Thiele Murder Lake Ontario State Parkway Hamlin, NY Cindy Thiele, Glenda Crittenden and Patricia Grimes were found in a cluster along Lake Ontario State Parkway in Hamlin, NY in a similar way to the victims on Ocean Parkway murdered by the Long Island Serial Killer in the late 1990s and 2000s. October 25 1992 Betty Gaddy Murder Lake Ontario State Parkway Hamlin, NY Betty Gaddy lived near where Kisha Sullivan who was murdered in 2002 lived in Rochester Betty Jean Gaddy was the fourth victim left in a cluster along Lake Ontario State Parkway at Lake Ontario around Hamlin, NY.
November 3 1992 Sandra Johnson Murder Lake Ontario State Parkway Hamlin, NY Sandra Johnson was the 5th woman found murdered and left in a cluster along Lake Ontario State Parkway in Hamlin, NY The Rochester Serial Killer cluster site is only 30 miles from where Rex Heuermann’s uncle lived in Pavilion, NY
The Rochester Serial Killer
December 7 1992 Victoria Jobson Murder Rochester, NY Victoria Jobson’s last known address was 512 Lake Street across the street from where Moraine Armstrong was murdered in her apartment by Robert Spahalski in 1990. Spahalski lived at 517 Lake at the time of Armstrong’s murder.
Rochester Serial Killer Suspect Robert Spahalski
January 20 1993 Melinda Juul Murder Jamestown, NY
Anonymous letter was received outlining a suspect and motive in Melinda Juul’s murder, just like the Beth-Ellen Vinson featured and first linked to the LISK case on Murder, Inc.
January 27 1993 Janine Clausen Murder Leicester, NY
Jeanine Clausen, victim #16 of the Rochester Serial Killer was found murdered only 16 miles from Rex Heuermann’s uncle leading Murder, Inc. to suspect Rex Heuermann may in fact be the Rochester Serial Killer
August 18 1993 Natalie Rippe Murder Rochester, NY
December 16 1993 Shamon Smith Murder Rochester, NY
June 17 1994 Jandell Broadnax Murder Rochester, NY
Rochester Serial Killer Suspect John White
September 13 1994 Greta Harmon Murder Middlebury, NY Greta Harmon was found dead in a wooded area in Middlebury, NY just 7 miles from Rex Heuermann’s uncle’s house in Pavilion, NY
April 2 1995 Jane Doe Torso Lake Ontario Shore, Wilson, NY
June 22 1996 Jane Doe Niagra River Lewiston, NY
August 13 1996 Tamika Battles Murder Buffalo, NY
April 23 1997 Ann Katherine Rippel Lee Murder Alexander, NY Annie Lee was bound around the mouth and head area with duct tape exactly like the Long Island Serial Killer Gilgo 4 victims. Annie Rippel was found murdered and bound with duct tape in Little Tonawanda Creek in Alexander, NY. Rex Heuermann’s uncle lived 8 miles staright east on Creek Rd in Pavilion, NY Cops claim Annie Lee “was not helped into the water.” Murder, Inc. is extremely skeptical of this police conclusion.
June 6 1997 Lori Ceci Bova Missing Lakewood, NY The Buffalo News, June 14, 1997
October 17 1997 Randy McConnell Missing Great Bend, PA
June 5 1998 Marla Ware Suspicious Death Oswego, NY
July 1 1998 Benjamin Gonzalez-Reyes Murder Arkwright, NY The Buffalo News, July 2, 1998, Page 2
July 22 1998 Angela Green Murder Rochester, NY
January 16 1999 Body Part Ellicot, NY The Buffalo News, January 17, 1999, Page 3.
February 9 1999 Betty Sanders Murder Buffalo, NY
February 10 1999 Cheryl Garcia Murder Buffalo, NY Cheryl Garcia and Betty Sanders were both found on the same street one day apart in Buffalo NY
May 5 2000 Eddie Freson Murder Buttermilk Falls LeRoy, NY Eddie Freson was found dead six miles from Rex Heuermann’s uncle’s house in Pavilion, NY
September 30 2000 Jacqueline McCalop Murder Hudson, NY Jacqueline McCalop was found murdered along in the Hudson River in Greenport, NY. Rex Heuermann’s grandfather, William Heuermann died in Copake, NY in 1964.
December 8 2001 Kisha Stanley Murder Alden, NY Kisha Stanley lived on College Street in Buffalo near where Mary Sanders disappeared
December 9 2001 Sharon Schechter Missing Perinton, NY
Sharon Schechter disappeared from Perinton, NY.
Her abandoned minivan was found in the parking lot of a Days Inn in Rochester.
February 10 2002 Catherine Smith Murder Hamlin, NY Catherine Smith was found murdered near the Rochester Serial Killer’s cluster site in Hamlin, NY
February 11 2002 Rose DiCicco Murder Rochester, NY 69 year old Rose DiCicco was found murdered under the bleachers at a school near her home in Rochester, NY only one day after an elderly woman named Catherine Smith was found murdered at her home near the Rochester Serial Killer’s cluster site in Hamlin, NY. Rose DiCicco was found murdered two blocks from where Moraine Armstrong was found bound and strangled with electrical cords in 1990 by Robert Spahalski.
August 20 2002 Regina Parmer Missing Niagra Falls, NY
August 29 2002 Jane Doe Murder Wolcott, NY The unidentified female found murdered and wrapped in a plastic shower curtain was found in the brush off West Port Bay Road in Wolcott, NY on Lake Ontario. The victim was seven months pregnant.
October 4 2002 Kisha Sullivan Missing Rochester, NY Kisha Sullivan disappeared walking to a deli in Rochester, NY near where Rochester Serial Killer victim Betty Gaddy and 2001 murder victim Penny Shicker lived
October 21 2002 Jeanine Cassidy Suspicious Death Perinton, NY Jeannine Cassidy was found in a creek about 2 miles from where Sharon Shechter disappeared in Dec 2001
October 27 2002 Kisha Sullivan Murder Le Roy, NY Kisha Sullivan was found murdered only 6 miles from Rex Heuermann’s uncle’s house in Pavilion, NY
November 9 2002 Regina Parmer Murder Niagra Falls, NY Regina Parmer’s skeletal remains were found in an isolated area of Carlton, NY 50 miles from where she disappeared in Niagra Falls, NY. Regina Parmer was found at the end of Lake Ontario State Parkway 17 miles west of the Rochester Serial Killer’s cluster site.
December 19 2002 Mary E. Stevens Murder Buffalo, NY
July 14 2003 Niagra Falls Jane Doe Murder Niagra Falls, NY
August 2003 Jennifer “Moonbeam” Hammond Missing Ballston Spa, NY
Jennifer Marie Hammond. Times Union
Jennifer Hammond disappeared from Ballston Spa, NY
August 10 2004 Yolanda Bindics Missing Jamestown, NY
June 2 2005 Journey Cooper Murder Buffalo, NY
June 30 2005 Christina White Missing Ballston Spa, NY
Christina White disappeared extremely close to where Jennifer Hammmond had vanished in Ballston Spa, NY
January 11, 2006 Bambi Lynn Madden Missing Winding Way & Oak Street, Binghamton, NY
Bambi Madden disappeared from Binghamton approximately 8 miles from where Rex Heuermann’s sister lived
A user named QueenB from the http://www.bcvoice.com forum may have first linked all the murders and disappearances of Bambi Madden, Keisha Roman, Bethanie Dougherty, Nicole Marranca and Judy Benjamin to the Long Island Serial Killer after identifying the pattern of murders and proximity to Rex Heuermann’s family’s residence.
March 10 2006 Christina White Murder Found Greenfield, NY Christina White’s skeletal remains were found in Greenfield, NY in the same area Jennifer Hammond’s skull would be found in 2009. Both disappeared near the same location in Ballston Spa, NY.
May 20 2006 Unidentified Female Namus UP 494 Torso Murder Niagra River, Lewiston, NY
June 1 2006 Penny Schicker Murder Williamson, NY Penny Schicker lived only a few blocks from Kisha Sullivan who was murdered in 2002
Penny Schicker was found murdered and left along the road in Williamson, NY
September 10 2006 Yolanda Bindics Murder Body Found Charlotte, NY Yolanda Bindics and Benjamin Gonzalez-Reyes were both found murdered near theEarl O. Cardot Eastside Overland Trail
January 2007 Traci Lynn Morris Douglass Missing Angelica, NY
April 21 2007 Jane Doe Murder Sterling, NY
November 11 2007 Denise Hart Missing Schenectady, NY
Rex Heuermann’s brother-in-law shows two residences within a mile from where Denise Hart worked
April 1 2008 Bethany Dougherty Missing Killawog, NY
A mid to late 90s Chevy S-10 style pick-up truck was in seen in the area around the time Bethanie Dougherty disappeared. Some models the Chevy S-10 are similar to the Chevy Avalanche
1999 Chevy S-10 Pick-up Truck Rex Heuermann’s Chevy Avalanche Bethanie Dougherty disappeared only 16 miles from Rex Heuermann’s sister’s house in Chenango Forks, NY Bethanie Dougherty’s cousin Marla Ware died under mysterious circumstances in Oswego, NY in 1998.
April 1 2008 Denise Hart Murder Menands, NY
Denise Hart’s torso was found wrapped in a plastic bag in a wooded area 12 miles away from Schenectady in Menands, NY A man who appears to be Rex Heuermann’s wife’s uncle lived in Wynantskill four miles east from where Denise Hart’s torso was found
May 1 2008 Lutricia Steele Missing Schenectady, NY Rex Heuermann’s wife’s family lives in Schenectady, NY
October 28 2008 Corrie Anderson Missing Jamestown, NY Corrie Anderson disappeared in Jamestown, a small town with a suspicious number of disappearances that lead Murder, Inc. to suspect the Long Island Serial Killer was frequenting the area for the past few decades.
March 22 2009 Keisha Roman Missing Oak Street Binghamton, NY
Keisha Roman disappeared just three blocks from where Bambi Madden vanished in 2006
Keisha Roman acted in a 2003 movie called Summer of Tomorrows
July 10 2009 Melissa Barthelemy Murder Long Island New York
According to an April 2011 interview with Christine Pelisek for the Daily Beast, Melissa’s pimp tried to file a missing persons report after Melissa never returned but cops refused. He tried to take police to the john’s house on Long Island where Melissa frequently went but the cops also refused and just followed Johnny Terry around instead.
A second phone of Barthelemy’s was used supposedly used as well, but in a narrative that makes no sense, cops said they traced it to an ex-con who picked it up after two girls fought on the street. Cops claim this was a fight between Barthelemy and another girl, but how could the killer have used this second phone if an ex-con picked it up on the street before Melissa disappeared?
Before her murder Melissa Barthelemy was harassed and arrested by the NYPD for “suspicion of prostitution” on the street in Manhattan.
The cops and G-Men knew the few block radius in Massapequa Park where the killer lived but every single one of them was too derelict, lazy and dumb to just drive around the block and look for the Chevy Avalanche parked outside Rex Heuermann’s house. Instead, they let the killer go free to murder many more victims and should be held accountable as accessories to the murders.
Rex Heuermann’s Chevy Avalanche was parked in plain sight on the street for years in the block radius where the G-Men and cops knew the Long Island Serial Killer lived but they didn’t investigate and let him go free
September 21 2009 Keisha Roman Murder Susquehanna, PA Keisha Roman was found murdered at a fishing boat launch on the Susquehanna River in Pennsylvania just 20 miles south of Rex Heuermann’s sister’s house in Chenango Forks, NY
September 26 2009 Traci Douglass Murder South Valley, NY Traci Douglass was found murdered on the banks of Allegany Reservoir just five days after Keisha Roman was found along the Susquehanna River. Douglass had disappeared two years earlier in January 2007.
October 25 2009 Jennifer Hammond Murder Skull Found Greenfield, NY Jennifer Hammond’s skull was found in the same area as Christina White’s skeletal remains. Both disappeared under similar circumstances from Ballston Spa, NY.
May 6 2010 Ashley Carroll Missing Albany, NY
August 7 2010 Deborah Maniace Suspicious Death Batavia, NY
August 1 2010 Rosita Sanders Murder Rochester, NY Rosita Sanders was found murdered 20 miles from where Rex Heuermann’s uncle lived in Pavilion, NY
September 22 2010 Jaklyn Baccoli Murder Rochester, NY Jaklyn Baccoli was found murdered in same area of Rochester as Azsia Grimes, Deborah Woodard and Rosalie Oppel
September 23 2010 James Schaefer Suspicious Death Binghamton, NY
James Schaefer was found dead in the woods along the Susquehanna River after disappearing on August 17, 2010. A second set of remains, those belonging to a woman, were later found at the same location in 2023.
December 19 2010 Wilnelia Salgado-Lacen Missing Jamestown, NY
August 29 2012 Loretta Gates Murder Niagra Falls, NY
September 9 2012 Loretta Gates Murder Head & Arm Found Hyde Park Niagra Falls, NY
October 12 2013 Amanda King Missing Glenville, NY
August 7 2015 Troy Hickman Drowning Batavia, NY
December 17 2015 Ephrata Jane Doe Murder Ephrata, NY
April 8 2016 Brenda Halpin Missing Chenango Bridge, NY Brenda Halpin disappeared from her home near where Rex Heuermann’s sister lived in Chenango Fork, NY
May 11 2016 Brenda Halpin Suspicious Drowning Binghamton, NY
September 5 2016 Kyeongseop Woodhams Suspicious Death Dewitt Park Batavia, NY
August 8 2017 Nicole Marranca Missing Ithaca, NY
April 21 2018 Brian Heyden Murder Portland, NY Brian Heyden was found murdered in a wooded area off Route 20 in Portland, NY near the Chautauqua Rails to Trails entrance. In 2021, two women were found murdered and hidden a few yards aparts in the woods off Woleben Road in Portland, NY near the Chatauqua Rails to Trails.
September 11 2020 Azsia Grimes Murder Rochester, NY
June 25 2021 Marquita Mull Missing Buffalo, NY
September 26 2021 Jane Doe Murder Skeletal Portland, NY
The unidentified female and Marquita Mull were found hidden in the same remote location in the woods in Portland, NY many years apart indicating a serial killer who has been active for decades is responsible for the cluster site on Woleben Road
September 27 2021 Marquita Mull Murder Portland, NY
Marquita Mull and the unidentified Jane Doe were murdered decades apart and hidden in the same spot in the woods on Woleben Road in Portland, NY
Marquita Mull and the unidentified female were found hidden in the woods only four miles from where Rebecca Nicholson was murdered in 1990 Brian Heyden’s body was discovered hidden in the woods in Portland, NY in 2018 not far from where Marquita Mull and Jane Doe were discovered in 2021
November 21 2021 Kevin Hornburg Missing Jamestown, NY
March 14 2022 Lewis Hyde Suspicious Death Batavia, NY
June 2022 Debra Scott Murder? Binghamton, NY
June 25 2022 Woman Found Rockbottom Dam Binghamton, NY
October 17 2022 Clarence Kewelski Murder? Jamestown, NY
October 25 2022 Unidentified Male Yin-yang Tattoo Buffalo, NY The unidentified male was found with a bedsheet possibly in a similar manner to the 2012 Manorville John Doe #3. The 2012 unidentified man in Manorville was found wrapped in a bed sheet or blanket, wrapped in garbage bags that were bound with duct tape and then bound with duct tape around the head area just like the Gilgo 4 female victims at Gilgo Beach on Ocean Parkway. Three males were found murdered and left in Manorville at the same Manorville cluster site as Jessica Taylor and Valerie Mack, one within days of Mack, but the Suffolk County Police Department and Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office have covered up the murders of these three males. The cops have even gone so far as to violate the Freedom of the Information Act and refuse to release the documents identifying the LISK victim’s identity to the public, which is public information under federal and state law. The cops chose to refuse to release the victim’s identity for the last decade after he was secretly identified, covering up the murder and refusing the opportunity to accept any information about the victim or killer from the public. This cover-up was exclusively exposed on Murder, Inc in 2020. The cops continue to cover up the male murders in Manorville to this day. The unidentified male was found in Buffalo where Marquita Mull disappeared from before she was found murdered and hidden in the woods in Portland, NY
February 25 2023 Judy Benjamin Missing Ninevah, NY Judy Benjamin disappeared only 13 miles from Rex Heuermann’s sister lived
May 11 2023 Woman’s Body Found Susquehanna River Binghamton, NY
The woman found on May 11, 2023 was located in the same exact location as the remains located on September 23, 2010.
MURDER, INC. EXCLUSIVE: Did the Nassau County Police Department frame an innocent man for murder in Massapequa and give the real killer a million dollars?
Captain John Underhill was an Englishman who fought to exterminate the native population for the British and Dutch Colonies in the Americas. John Underhill is responsible for many of the most violent and horrific crimes in history and was one of the worst men to ever live. In 1637 Underhill attacked a Pequot fort along the Mystic River on behalf of the Connecticut Colony slaughtering 700 men, woman and children. In 1643 Director of New Netherland Willem Kieft sent soldiers from New Amsterdam to Pavonia in present day Jersey City, NJ where they butchered over 80 Lenape men, women and children in their sleep. David de Vries watched the massacre and gave the following description:
The same night Maryn Adriansen and his soldiers murdered over 40 men, women and children of the Wecquaesgeek band of the Wappinger while they slept at the Massacre at Corlears Hook. In March 1644 Captain John Underhill burned 700 women, children and tribal elders alive at the Pound Ridge Massacre on behalf of the New Netherland Colony. In 1644 Captain John Underhill massacred over 120 of the Massapequa at their winter encampment at Fort Massapeag in present day Massapequa, NY.
On February 2, 1933 the dead body of 15 year old Mary Helen O’Connor was found in the brush of a wooded area near Ontario Ave and Hicksville Road in Massapequa. Mary O’Connor had disappeared from the LIRR Station in the East New York section of Brooklyn. Infamously horrific serial killer Albert Fish (aka The Gray Man, The Brooklyn Vampire and the Werewolf of Wysteria) is believed to be responsible for her murder. Mary O’Connor’s friend lived at a hotel where Albert Fish worked and Fish had purportedly sent O’Connor an obscene letter. He had also previously worked in Massapequa. Albert Fish was arrested in 1934 for the murder of Grace Budd after sending her mother an anonymous taunting letter describing how he ate the child. Albert Fish was executed at Sing Sing in 1936.
On September 13, 1963 alleged Long Island Serial Killer Rex Heuermann was born and lived at 105 1st Ave in Massapequa Park, NY for his entire life until his arrest for the Gilgo Beach murders on July 13, 2023.
In 1966 Massapequa was plagued by a serial rapist known as the Massapequa Masked Rapist who broke into homes and terrorized victims in the middle of the night. Murder, Inc. is believed to have solved these crimes after identifying serial killer Richard Cottingham as the perpetrator thanks to the work of Jennifer Weiss. Richard Cottingham’s uncle lived in Massapequa approximately 1.25 miles straight west on the other side of the preserve from Rex Heuermann.
On January 11, 1977, 17 year old Steven Arnold, of 1 Westgate Rd, Massapequa Park, kidnapped a 21 year old woman from the Sunrise Mall in Massapequa and forced her to drive to a street near the bay where he sexually assaulted her. Arnold was subsequently arrested.
On July 17, 1984 11 year old Massapequa Park resident Angela Wong disappeared near her house. Her brother and his friends went looking for her in the woods and heard a scream and a whistle they thought might be her but were frightened and ran off. The dead body of Angela Wong was found in a creek bed the next day. She’d been beaten, drowned, her pants were pulled down and a log was placed on the back of her neck holding her head underwater. Two hairs were recovered from her body.
On November 2, 1985 a 12 year old girl was asleep in her home on East Lake Drive in Massapequa Park when a man snuck in at 4 am, snatched her from her bed and carried her out a window. As the kidnapper was dragging the struggling girl through the neighbor’s yard, the neighbor happened to turn his light on, scaring the kidnapper off. Serial rapist and suspected child murderer Steven Arnold lived on and had a relative who lived on East Lake Drive in Massapequa Park.
On December 23, 1986 Richard Hanan disappeared after leaving his home in Massapequa. The 74 year old man had told his family he worked as a process server but apparently hadn’t held the job in over six months. Hanan’s body was found by a duck hunter under a tarp in a field in Oak Beach approximately 90 feet from Ocean Parkway.
On July 22, 1992 Steven Arnold attacked a woman near the Massapequa train station. He was arrested and while in the Nassau County Jail badly beaten by inmates. Arnold sued Nassau County and won $900,000. Steven Arnold was also convicted of the assault and sentenced to 5 to 15 years.
At 8:00 pm on the night of March 22, 1994 an intruder kicked in the door to Maxine Small’s basement apartment in East Massapequa and shot her. Small managed to call 911 and say she’d been shot but died later at the hospital. She was 26 years old, engaged to be married and pregnant. She’d had an argument and shoving match with her landlord’s son, Marc Laviolette, on the day before her murder and cops had been called to the residence. Six shells casings were recovered from the crime scene.
On November 3, 1995 Lottie Dietel was found murdered in the basement of her Massapequa Park home. She’d been stabbed in the torso and back with a kitchen knife. Lottie Dietel was 75 years old and lived with her husband Arnold who ran Al’s Army & Navy Surplus Store in Farmingdale, NY. Dietel’s husband and son were at the Army Navy store at the time of the murder. When they returned home at 1 pm they found Dietel murdered. Rex Heuermann collected firearms and owned an Army Jeep he kept parked in the driveway of his Massapequa Park home, which was only one mile straight south of Lottie Dietel’s house.
In 2002, the Nassau County Police Department framed Angela Wong’s neighbor Manuel Pacheco for her 1984 murder despite the fact his DNA didn’t match the hair recovered from Angela Wong’s underwear. The DNA reports were withheld from Manuel Pacheco by the Nassau County Police Department and Nassau County District Attorney’s Office in order to frame him. Manuel Pacheco maintained his innocence and after 17 years was finally allowed access to the DNA reports after the Innocence Project of New York got involved. The reports showed that Manuel Pacheco was excluded as a contributor to mitochondrial DNA recovered from Angela Wong’s body. In 2001 the Nassau County Police Department had learned that Manny Pacheco has been excluded as a contributor to the mitochondrial DNA found in Angela Wong’s underwear.
In 2001 the Nassau County Police Department also learned the DNA was consistent with convicted serial rapist Steven Arnold of Massapequa Park who lived on the other side of Sunrise Mall from where Angela Wong was murdered. The Nassau County Police Department and Nassau County District Attorney chose to hide this from Manny Pacheco, frame him for a murder he didn’t commit, and let Steven Arnold, a serial rapist and prime suspect in Wong’s murder who they paid a million dollars to, go free to live in Massapequa Park where he resides to this day, just half a mile from Rex Heuermann’s home.
February 2 1933 Mary Helen O’Connor Murder Massapequa, NY Mary O’Connor was found murdered in the brush on Ontario Ave near Hicksville Road in Massapequa, NY. Serial killer Albert Fish is believed to be responsible for her murder.
October 25 1966 Massapequa Masked Rapist Massapequa, NY November 4 1966 Massapequa Masked Rapist Massapequa, NY November 2? 1966 Massapequa Masked Rapist Massapequa, NY Richard Cottingham’s uncle Hugh Cottingham lived in Massapequa near Rex Heuermann
1977 Rex Heuermann McKenna Jr. High School Massapequa Park, NY
January 12 1977 Steven Arnold Arrest Massapequa, NY Steven Arnold kidnapped a woman from the Sunrise Mall just a block from where he lived on Westgate Ave in Massapequa. Arnold lived a half mile from Rex Heuermann’s home in Massapequa Park.
September 28 1980 Massapequa Arson Massapequa Park, NY
July 18 1984 Angela Wong Murder Massapequa, NY *Manuel Pacheco Framed* Angela Wong was found murdered in a creek in Massapequa Rex Heuermann lived less than 1 mile from where Angela Wong’s body was found Serial rapist Steven Arnold lived in Massapequa Park half a mile from where Angela Wong was murdered. Steven Arnold’s mitochondrial DNA is allegedly consistent with the mitochondrial DNA recovered from Angela Wong’s body
November 2 1985 Massapequa Park Kidnapper Massapequa Park, NY Convicted Serial Rapist Steven Arnold LIVED ON THE SAME STREET in Massapequa Park as the house where a 12 year old was kidnapped out of her bed at 4:00 am. This was only one year after Angela Wong’s murder. The kidnapping was half a mile from Rex Heuermann’s home in Massapequa Park, NY
January 22 1987 Richard Hannan Murder Oak Beach, NY (Missing Dec 23 Massapequa, NY) Massapequa resident Richard Hanan was found bludgeoned to death on Ocean Parkway by a duck hunter
May 18 1987 Judith Beckford Murder East Massapequa, NY Judith Beckford was murdered in her East Massapequa home by a gunshot wound to the head. Her boyfriend Laurel Thompson was charged with her murder but it’s unclear if he was convicted.
August 10 1987 Kidnapping Attempt Massapequa, NY *Carl Coluzzi Conviction* Convicted kidnapper Carl Coluzzi and convicted serial rapist Steven Arnold were neighbors in Massapequa near the Sunrise Mall
November 7 1989 Eric Wagner Murder East Massapequa, NY
July 22 1992 Steven Arnold Arrest Massapequa, NY
June 25 1993 Body Found Tobay Beach, NY
October 3 1993 Choices Club Massapequa, NY
January 7 1994 Massapequa Arson Massapequa Park, NY This arson occurred less than a mile from Rex Heuermann’s home
March 20 1994 Maxine Small Murder East Massapequa, NY Maxine Small was shot to death in her East Massapequa apartment approximately 1 mile from Rex Heuermann’s residence
May 5 1997 Choices Swingers Club Shutdown Massapequa, NY
January 10 1999Choices Swingers Club is Living Hope Fellowship Baptist Church Massapequa, NY Choices swingers club and Living Hope Fellowship Baptist Church in Massapequa were located in the same lot as the Budget Inn, mentioned in relation to Melissa Barthelemy’s phone pings
February 10 2000 Skeletal Remains Massapequa, NY
March 26 2002 Manuel Pacheco Framed by Nassau County Police Department for Angela Wong Murder Massapequa, NY Nassau County Police Detectives Michael Kuhn & William Cocks framed Manuel Pacheco for Angela Wong’s murder along with numerous other cops and the Nassau County District Attorney’s Office including prosector Robert T. Hayden. How many other people have Robert Hayden, the Nassau County DA’s Office and the Nassau County Police Department? Manuel Pacheco’s mother warned the public that the Nassau County Police Department and DA were framing her son for murder Manuel Pacheco was framed and caged for 20 years by the Nassau County Police Department and Judge Donald E. Belfi despite that fact his DNA didn’t match hairs found on Angela Wong’s body Angela Wong DNA Reports Withheld from Manuel Pacheco Mitochondrial DNA recovered from Angela Wong was consistent with Massapequa Park serial rapist Steven Arnold who was identified as a suspect in 2001 but the Nassau County Police Department and Nassau County District Attorney chose to frame an innocent man and let the real killer go free.
May 15 2004 Choices Swingers Club is Living Hope Fellowship Baptist Church Massapequa, NY
September 15 2022 Manuel Pacheco PAROLED Nassau County, NY
December 11 2023 Steven Arnold Sex Offender Massapequa Park, NY Steven Arnold lives only half a mile from Long Island Serial Killer suspect Rex Heuermann. Has Arnold been excluded as a contributor to the mitochondrial DNA recovered from the LISK victims? Do Rex Heuermann and Steven Arnold know each other?
Murder, Inc. Exclusive: Investigation of unsolved serial murders in North Carolina & South Carolina and possible victims of the Long Island Serial Killer
On February 21, 1990 20 year old Autumn Lee Cox disappeared after leaving her home in Concord, NC. Cox told her mother she was hitchiking to Asheville to see her boyfriend. On July 5, 1992 her skeletal remains were recovered by a man picking blackberries behind the old Spartan Undies plant in Spartanburg, SC nearly 90 miles away from her home in Concord. Autumn Lee Cox’s home was only 12 miles south of Long Island Serial Killer suspect Rex Heuermann’s brother Craig Heuermann’s home in China Grove, NC where he lived in the 1990s.
On July 18, 1990 Madelyn Cox Thomas disappeared from Gastonia, NC. Police claimed she may been involved in recreational drug use and sex work. One week later on July 25, 1990 Pamela Mitchell Hoy disappeared from Alamance, NC. Her van was found abandoned backed into a parking spot at the Days Inn on Randleman Road in Greensboro, NC.
On August 24, 1990 the dismembered torso of a woman was found along Davis Chapel Rd in Spartanburg, SC. The woman’s head, feet and one hand hand been cut off and were missing. In 2013, she was identified as Madelyn Cox Thomas, who disappeared one month earlier.
On September 19, 1990 the partially nude body of a woman was found off the side of Interstate 40 in Hillsborough, NC. The woman was described as 15 to 25, 5’3 and 110 pounds. Her pink sweatshirt was tied around her neck and she was wearing only a bra and socks. At the time police stated they couldn’t determine a cause of death but suspected foul play. 33 years later in September 2023, genetic genealogists identified the woman as Lisa Coburn Kesler using a degraded hair sample recovered from the crime scene. Now police say Lisa Coburn Kesler was strangled and the positioning of her body and clothing found was very unique. The Orange County Sheriff’s Department says they now have a person of interest in the case.
On November 6, 1990 the nude body of Kathy Clark Fogleman was found in the woods by a hunter at Mount Hope Church Road and Alamance Road in Liberty, NC in Guilford County. She’d been sexually assaulted and run over by an automobile. She disappeared from Burlington, NC a few days before after calling a cab. The next day, November 7, 1990, the skeletal remains of Pamela Mitchell Hoy were found at Mount Hope Church Road and Alamance Road wrapped in a quilt and bound with rope around the arms and legs. Hoy and Fogleman were found only 500 yards apart. Both women also lived in Burlington, NC. A cab driver named Keith Allen Brown who picked up Kathy Fogleman on the night she disappeared was arrested for her murder. Brown plead not guilty to Fogleman’s murder and claimed he had nothing to do with Pamela Hoy’s murder. He killed himself in his jail cell on the eve of his trial. Keith Brown had served 5 years in prison for sexually assaulting, stabbing a woman and leaving her for dead in 1981 about a mile from where Hoy and Fogleman were found.
On November 22, 1990 the body of 18 year old Hope Gibson was found under a mattress in the woods in Hopkins, SC outside of Columbia. Gibson had disappeared on her way to a job interview. The cops had no clues so they theorized she died from sniffing gasoline and her friends hid her body there.
On December 7, 1990 15 year old Amy Danielle Gibson disappeared after leaving her house in Greensboro, NC and was never seen again.
On April 3, 1991 Tina Marie Crouch, 20, disappeared after walking to the store in Gaffney, SC. She has never been found. Gaffney is approximately 30 miles northwest of where Rex Heuermann would later buy property.
On June 23, 1991 seven year old Jennifer Nicole Patterson disappeared from the Holly Hills Mobile Home Park on Bragg Boulevard in Spring Lake, NC near Fayetteville. She was never seen again.
On August 29, 1991 two hunters found the skull of a woman on top of a sawdust pile. More partial skeletal remains were discovered but at least some of the woman’s arms or limbs were not. She was believed to have been killed around 10 years earlier and suffered a gunshot wound to her skull. She has never been identified.
On February 1, 1992 the burned body of a male was found in a wooded area off Billet Road in Guilford County, NC. The man had been shot once in the head execution style and set on fire. He was described as a white or hispanic male who was six feet tall.
On March 1, 1992 Rita Maxwell disappeared after leaving her home on Dundeen Street in Charlotte, NC. Later that month on March 25, 1992 Rita’s friend Devonne Dubose also disappeared in Charlotte.
On April 19, 1992 Sherry Mash was found strangled to death in a ditch in Salisbury, NC. She lived in Salisbury and worked at the Dominion Yarn factory in Landis near China Grove where Rex Heuermann’s brother Craig Heuermann lived in the 1990s. Sherry Mash was found murdered ten miles from Craig Heuermann’s China Grove address.
On June 8, 1992 Clemson University student Norsaadah Husain disappeared from a laundromat in Clemson, SC. Her skeletal remains were later found in the woods in Seneca, SC in September 1992.
On June 24, 1992 Judy Leggett disappeared after visiting her sister on Dundeen Street in Charlotte. Her sister’s neighbor was Rita Maxwell, who had also vanished in March 1992.
On September 11, 1992 the nude body of Katherine Price was found by hunters in the woods 150 yard off NC 150 in Mill Bridge, NC. Her body was found less than five miles from where Rex Heuermann’s brother Craig Heuermann lived in the 1990s.
On January 2, 1993 rabbit hunters discovered the skeletal remains of Anna Caroline Lake in Wellford, SC. Anna Lake was 20 years old and lived at her grandparents house in Duncan when she disappeared on August 30, 1990. The suspicious similarities between the unsolved murders of Autumn Lee Cox, Madelyn Cox Thomas and Anna Caroline Lake were noted in the press at the time.
On June 24, 1994 the nude body of Kenya Latrice Lucas was found in Winston-Salem, NC after an anonymous caller phoned police and said there was a body of a woman off a path in the woods. Kenya Lucas was 16 years old and had been strangled to death. Her arms were bound behind her back. She disappeared on June 21 after going to sleep over at her friend’s house.
Two days later 30 year old Valerie Ann Rogers disappeared in Winston-Salem, NC. On July 6, 1994 her faceless and partially decomposed body was found floating in Salem Creek in the woods.
On July 27 1994 the skeletal remains of Ruby Mae Commander were found hidden in a ditch and covered in pine branches in Pullen Park in Raleigh, NC.
On August 16, 1994 17 year old Beth-Ellen Vinson disappeared after leaving to go on a 2:30 am date with a client through an escort agency in Raleigh, NC. Vinson’s car was found abandoned with the windows down, music playing and her right shoe on the floor. Her body was found stabbed to death and covered with cardboard on August 23, 1994 in a wooded ditch a few blocks from where her car had been discovered. After Beth-Ellen Vinson’s unsolved murder, a newspaper received an anonymous letter claiming Vinson worked as an escort for clients with “unique tastes” and was murdered because she was blackmailing someone who was a member of a sadomasochist group called “The Power Exchange of the Triangle”.
On September 8, 1994 the body of a woman was found murdered in the lot behind a K-Mart in Raleigh, NC. Cops received an anonymous tip identifying the woman as 28 year old Tracy Ann Moschette. Cops claimed there was no connection to Beth-Ellen Vinson who had been murdered in Raleigh two weeks before.
On September 26, 1994 Debra Asbury disappeared in Lexington, NC after heading to the store to go shopping and was never seen again. Lexington is 20 miles north of Craig Heuermann’s home in China Grove, NC.
On January 20, 1995 Debra Southerly vanished from Walterboro, SC and was never seen again.
On February 6, 1995 the body of Sherray Gaines was found in the woods in Charlotte, NC. Gaines had been arrested and charged by cops numerous times for recreational drug use and sex work. Sherray Gaines was found murdered in the woods behind Dundeen Street where both Rita Maxwell and Judy Leggett.
On July 11, 1995 Lois Jean Whaley disappeared in Salisbury, NC. Whaley was a 5’2, 45 year old social worker who lived on N Main Street. Rex Heuermann’s brother Craig Heuermann also lived on N Main Street eight miles south in China Grove. Whaley’s car was found abandoned in Salisbury. On July 18, 1995 Lois Whaley’s body was found in a field in Rowan County 18 miles east of Craig Heuermann’s home. She’d been strangled to death.
On January 1, 1996 a man was seen dumping what appeared to be a body wrapped in burlap from a boat in the Saluda River in Newberry, SC. Police searched the river at the time but nothing was located. Murder, Inc. was unable to locate any follow up reports.
On March 4, 1996 Betty Lou Hamilton disappeared after leaving her home in Charlotte, NC. Four days later Kathi Warren also disappeared in Charlotte after attending a concert. On March 22, 1996 the body of Patricia Horace was discovered under a pile of truck tires in a lot behind a business in Charlotte.
On June 13, 1996 45 year old Linda Lawrence disappeared in Rocky Mount, NC after last beeing seen at a swimming pool. The automobile she was driving was later found abandoned and she was never seen again.
On July 12, 1996 the body of Betty Hamilton was found hidden between piles of wooden pallets in the same lot where Patricia Horace had been discovered in March. Their bodies were found only 120 feet apart. Police said Hamilton and Horace were both dancers at strip clubs nearby and claimed both victims were involved in recreational crack cocaine use. Their murders, along with the murder of Judy Leggett and the disappearances of Devonne Dubose and Rita Maxwell from Dundeen Street led to the cops publicly admitting the killings could be the work of a serial killer.
Six days later on July 18, 1996 skeletal remains of a female were found in Charlotte in the brush near train tracks. The woman has never been identified.
On September 5, 1996 the nude body of 16 year old Antorya Newsome was discovered in the woods in Charlotte. She had disappeared on June 22, 1996.
On December 11, 1996 Sheila Manley was found along a highway exit ramp in Blacksburg, SC. She’d been beaten and bludgeoned to death.
On February 27, 1997 Clemson University student Stacey Holsonback was murdered and found floating in Lake Hartwell in Clemson, SC. Her murder is similar to the 1992 killing of Norsaadah Husain.
On March 2, 1997 the body of 18 year old Sheila Bryant was found face down on an embankmet at a gravel pit in Kannapolis, NC. She was found wearing only socks and shoes and her bra was pulled up over head. She’d been killed by asphyxiation after the murderer put an object down her throat. More of her clothes were found at a nearby campsite. Sheila Bryant lived and disappeared only 8 miles from Craig Heuermann. Her body was found only 15 miles from his house.
On March 18 1997 Paula Pressley Thomason disappeared in Piedmont, SC. Her partially decomposed body was found wrapped in a shroud and hidden in the weeds behind an abandoned garbage dump in Anderson, SC on May 8, 1997.
On April 10, 1997 Judy Smith disappeared on her way to see the Liberty Bell while on a trip to Philadelphia with her husband. Her skeletal remains were later found at a camping site in Candler, NC near Asheville. The bones showed cut marks leading the medical examiner to state she’d been stabbed to death. Philly to Asheville is over 600 miles. Rex Heuermann’s sister lived in Philadelphia.
On June 7, 1997 the body of 20 year old Amber Lundgren was found in a culvert near a recreation park in Asheville, NC. She’d been stabbed to death and some of her bloody clothes were found near her body. Amber Lundgren’s body was found close to the spot where Pamela Murray’s body was found in 1987.
On August 7, 1997 Garnetta Davis’s nude body was found in the weeds behind a business along the French Broad River in Asheville, NC. Garnetta Davis was only 19. She’d been arrested and charged by cops for recreational drug paraphernelia and for sex work related charges. Garnetta Davis disliked the cops so much that, according to them, she stood across from the police station and threw rocks at them. Garnetta Davis was neighbors with Amber Lundgren, but cops claimed the murders were not connected. They never solved either of them.
On September 7, 1997 the skeletal remains of Judy Smith were found scattered in the woods near a camp site in Asheville, NC. She’d disappeared in April from Philadelphia while on a trip with her husband. Some of her belongings were found buried in the woods.
On December 8, 1997 a man in Winston-Salem, NC found his dog chewing on a skull in the yard. A search led to more skeletal remains determined to belong to a 36 year old woman named Ernestine Howard.
On January 7, 1998 5 year old Brittany Locklear was kidnapped from a bus stop by a man driving a pickup truck with overhead lights in Raeford, NC. She was found murdered in a ditch three miles from her home.
On March 25, 1998 Vicky Duncan was found bludgeoned to death behind an abandoned house on a rural road in Rock Hill, SC. Duncan was found murdered 16 miles from Rex Heuermann’s property in Chester, SC.
On December 24, 1998 Bobbie Jo Doster Johnson disappeared from Concord, NC. On December 28, 1998 she was found strangled to death in the woods in Kannapolis, NC only ten miles from Craig Heuermann’s house in China Grove, NC.
On November 7, 1999 the body of Patricia Lapsinkes was found in a wooded lot in Fayetteville, NC. Cops claimed Lapsinkes was involved in sex work and had died by asphyxiation possibly from strangulation. She was found murdered near the site of several similar crimes going back to at least 1987.
On November 29, 1999 the remains of Maurice Hauser were found hidden between two mulch piles in Bethabara Park in Winston-Salem, NC. Hauser was found wearing women’s clothing and had been shot in the head just like Andre “Sugar Bear” Isaac. Hauser had last been seen in October and had recently been caged by cops for 20 days for “loitering for the purpose of prostitution”, a discriminatory and unconstitutional charge that cops around the country use to harass and cage transgender people for simply being on the street. Maurice Hauser was found murdered only two months after Samantha Parkes. Both victims lived in Winston-Salem, were in the same line of work, were found only 2.5 miles apart from each other and both had been killed by being shot in the head. The son of Rex Heuermann’s mother’s boyfriend of 37 years bought a home in Winston-Salem in 2021 about 3 miles from where Maurice Hauser was found murdered in 1999.
On February 14, 2000 nine year old Asha Degree disappeared from her home in Shelby, SC. She was allegedly seen walking along Highway 18. Her pencil, candy wrappers and a Mickey Mouse bow tie were found in the tool shed of an upholstery shop near where she disappeared. In August 2001 her backpack was found buried at construction site on Highway 18 over 26 miles from where she lived. The backpack was wrapped in two plastic garbage bags. The bag also contained two items that did not belong to Asha Degree, a New Kids on the Block shirt and the Dr. Suess book McElligot’s Pool. Law enforcement chose not to release the strange items found to the public for 17 years, ensuring that the memories of anyone who might recognize them were long faded. Asha may have been seen getting into a rusty Ford Thunderbird or Lincoln Mark IV with two occupants. Asha Degree is missing to this day. Rex Heuermann’s alleged search history lists: “10 year old black girl”.
On March 7, 2000 Amanda Bagley was found murdered in the woods in Fayetteville, NC. Amanda Bagley was 21 and cops claimed she was involved in sex work. Her murder caused cops to form a task force to try and investigate several similar unsolved murders in Fayetteville going back to 1987 suspected to be the work of a serial killer.
On November 9, 2001 Felicia Coleman disappeared from Goldsboro, NC. One month later on December 7, 2001 hunters found the skull of a woman in the woods near the Neuse River outside Goldsboro in Wayne County, NC. The medical examiner concluded the remains belonged to a black male. Cops later listed Felicia Coleman as being conclusively ruled out as a match for the identity of the skull. This is because cops can rule out potential matches in Namus at their discretion, rendering the credibility of the database compromised and inaccurate. In 2021, the skull was positively identified as belonging to Felicia Coleman.
On August 15, 2002 nine year old Jennifer Short was kidnapped from her home in Bassett, VA after both of her parents were shot in the head and killed. Jennifer Short’s skeletal remains were found in September in Stoneville, NC. Rex Heuermann owned hundreds of firearms, is alleged to have searched for images of girls around Jennifer Short’s age and Heuermann’s mother’s boyfriend’s son lived in Danville, VA about 20 miles from Bassett, VA and Stoneville, NC.
On March 30, 2003 the nude body of 23 year old Michelle Anne Driggers was found near an overgrown cemetery in the woods off Hestertown Road in Lumberton, NC. Driggers clothes were scattered around her body and she’d been bludgeoned in the head. Cops had arrested and charged Michelle Driggers with prostitution in the past. She was last seen in the area of Chippewa Street on the night of her murder.
On July 12, 2003 Lisa Hardin was found murdered in the woods behind a warehouse off Chippewa Street in Lumberton, NC. Hardin was badly beaten and strangled. Her t-shirt was “pulled over her chest and her underwear was twisted around her right ankle.” Cops had also arrested and charged Lisa Hardin, who was 36, with prostitution in the past.
On September 14, 2003 18 year old Katherine Alice Moody disappeared in Kannapolis, NC ten miles from Craig Heuermann’s house in China Grove, NC. She was found murdered and her body left behind an abandoned house 14 miles from where Craig Heuermann lived.
On March 3, 2004 Betsy Dickens was found murdered and lying face down in a field in Hickory, NC. Cops had arrested and charged Dickens numerous times for recreational drug use and sex work. Dickens was killed by blunt force trauma to the head. On April 9, 2004 Cynthia Lail was found badly beaten in Hickory, NC and later died of her wounds.
On April 17, 2004 the badly beaten and burned body of 15 year old Silene Eaddy was found in Hopkins, SC. Eaddy was found near where Hope Gibson’s body was discovered in 1990.
On October 2, 2004 the partial skull of an unidentified female was found in abandoned house in Pembroke near Lumberton, NC.
On April 19, 2005 the body of Amanda Dell Pike was found in the French Broad River in Asheville, NC. Pike had been harassed and arrested by cops for recreational drug use and sex work related crimes going back to at least 1997.
On December 14, 2006 the skeletal remains of Christi Hanks were found in a field a few hundred yards off Wright School Road in Belton, SC in Anderson County. Hanks was found bound and gagged with duct tape like victims of the Long Island Serial Killer at Gilgo Beach and had been murdered by suffocation. Christi Hanks lived in Anderson, SC and was reported missing by her daughter on August 4, 2006. Cops refused to investigate her disappearance, claimed she was involved in sex work and never solved her murder.
On November 28, 2007, Gaffney, SC resident Verlisha Littlejohn disappeared while heading to the Charles Lea Center, a group home for people with disabilities, where she worked. Her body was found nude in the Broad River in Cherokee Falls on January 4, 2008. Despite Verlisha Littlejohn’s family’s pleas the Cherokee County Sheriff’s Department refused to investigate her murder.
On April 8, 2008 22 year old Jamie Fraley disappeared from her apartment in Gastonia, NC. Her cellphone was found tossed in the woods near where she lived. She’s never been seen again. Cops suspected Fraley’s boyfriend’s father Ricky Simonds Sr. was involved in her murder…and then he was found dead in the trunk of his ex-girlfriend’s car. Cops theorized Ricky Simonds Sr. climbed into the trunk of the car and died from the heat.
On April 26, 2008 the skeletal remains of Allison Jackson-Foy and Angela Nobles Rothen were discovered at a cluster site in a small wooded area behind a former Mexican restaurant on Carolina Beach Road in Wilmington, NC. Cops released a composite sketch of a man who was seen multiple times near the cluster site and was described as a white man in his 50s who was 6’3. Cops suspect a convicted rapist named Timothy Iaconne of the murders. Allison Jackson Foy had previously lived in Massapequa approximately one mile from Rex Heuermann.
On May 4, 2008 Jennifer Rivkin disappeared in Gastonia, NC. Her abandoned car was found in the parking lot behind a restaurant. Jennifer Rivkin was never seen again.
On July 16, 2008 Lucy Johnson was shot and killed in her home, which was then set on fire, in Gaston, NC. Cops framed her husband but he was acquitted at trial. Lucy Johnson lived only half a mile from Jamie Fraley, who disappeared only two months earlier.
On September 27, 2008 the skeletal remains of a woma were found in the woods in St Matthews, SC. Cops have not been able to figure out her identify.
On August 9, 2009 Stacey Lester disappeared after last being seen at the Tuomey Regional Medical Center in Sumter, SC.
On December 23, 2009 Jahela Lucero-Menor, a 19 year old girl from Greensboro, NC was reported missing. On April 10, 2010 her skeletal remains were discovered in the woods along Mount Hope Church Road in Julian, NC near the same location where Kathy Fogleman and Pamela Hoy were found murdered in 1990.
On March 17, 2011 the partial skeletal remains of a woman were found in a wooded area near the highway in Charlotte, NC. She has never been identified.
On October 26, 2011 teenagers found the remains of a woman under a tarp and hidden underneath a couch in the woods behind a house in Startex, SC. She has not been identified.
On August 23, 2012 Crystal Dawn Morrison disappeared in Concord, NC. Her skeletal remains were later found in 2019 in the woods in Concord ten miles from Craig Heuermann’s home in China Grove, NC.
On November 25, 2014 18 year old Aaliyah Bell disappeared after leaving her grandmother’s house in Rock Hill, SC. She was never seen again. Bell disappeared 17 miles from Rex Heuermann’s property in Chester, SC.
On February 4, 2015 Sarah Graham disappeared after leaving her house for work at 6:30 am in Fairmont, NC. Her van was found abandoned in McDonald near Lumberton, NC.
On January 7, 2016 Tyarra Williams disappeared after leaving a friend’s house across the street from where she lived in Greensboro, NC. She was never seen again. Rex Heuermann’s mother’s boyfriend died in Greensboro in 2018.
On August 28, 2016Carmen Marie Gonzalez-Pinto disappeared in Charlotte, NC. After Carmen disappeared her mother received a phone call from Carmen’s number but only heard men’s voices in the background on the call.
On October 22, 2016 skeletal remains were found in a self-storage unit on Carpenter Fletcher Road in Durham, NC. The unit was being cleared out of the person renting the unit died. Inside was found the skeletal remains of a woman in plastic. The woman was identified as Melissa Poitra, who disappeared in 2005.
On November 23, 2016 Rhonda Kelley disappeared in Greenwood, SC and was never seen again. Cops had arrested and charged Rhonda Kelley for sex work related charges numerous times. In 2013, cops had arrested and charged Rhonda Kelley for accepting $10 dollars in exchange for sex.
On March 29, 2017 the skeletal remains of a male were found wrapped in plastic in the woods off a dirt trail in Mount Airy, NC. The man has never been identified.
On April 17, 2017 cops in Lumberton, NC responded to a call of a foul odor emanating from an abandoned house at 505 Peachtree Street. Inside they found the decomposing body of Christina Bennett wrapped in a blanket and hidden in a tv cabinet. Outside they found the body of Rhonda Jones stuffed in a garbage can. The cause of death for the women was ruled undetermined because of decomposition, but possible asphyxiation was noted. Cocaine was found in the womens’ systems. A woman named Megan Oxendine who had been inside the abandoned house gave an interview to the news about Bennett and Jones’ murders.
On June 3, 2017 Megan Oxendine was found murdered behind an abandoned house in Lumberton two blocks from where Christina Bennett and Rhonda Jones’ bodies had been discovered. Oxendine was gagged and had a wound to the head. The last person to see her alive was a woman named Cynthia Jacobs.
In July 2017 Cynthia Jacobs disappeared after last being seen a few blocks from where the Christina Bennett, Rhonda Jones and Megan Oxendine were found murdered.
On Spetember 25, 2017 20 year old Abby Patterson was living at her grandmother’s house on East 9th Street in Lumberton, NC when she disappeared after getting into a car (possibly a brown Buick). She was never seen again. Her home was only three blocks from where Christina Bennett, Rhonda Jones and Megan Oxendine were found murdered only month earlier.
On July 8, 2018 the body of Rita Maynor was found in an abandoned house in Lumberton, NC only a few blocks from where Megan Oxendine, Christina Bennett and Rhonda Jones had been found murdered.
On September 17, 2018 the body of Lisa Allen was found wrapped in a blanket and dumped along the road in Greenville, SC.
On February 4, 2019Erlin Noemi Padilla Valenzuela vanished from Greenville, SC. She disappeared a few blocks from where Lila Martin was last seen in 2004 before she too was never seen again.
On June 17, 2019 the skeletal remains of Teresa Sell were found by a pet dog in Seneca, SC. Her bones were found along a creek in a wooded area.
On September 8, 2019 the skull of a woman was found by a hunter in the woods in Rural Hall, NC. More partial skeletal remains were recovered after a search. The woman has not been identified. The woman was found in Rural Hall, NC only 8 miles from Rex Heuermann’s mother’s boyfriend’s son’s house.
On September 20, 2019 the badly burned body of Melissa Whitis was found in a ditch in Chester, SC. Melissa Whitis was found murdered only 9 miles from Rex Heuermann’s property in Chester, SC! Melissa Whitis’ father called for cops to investigate Heuermann’s possible connection to his daughter’s murder.
On November 11, 2019Naydelin Rodriguez-Lopez disappeared from Rock Hill, SC. The 17 year old left a note for her foster parents saying she was running away and was never seen again.
On November 24, 2019 34 year old Tammy Grady disappeared in Wilson, NC after leaving a motel.
On May 13, 2020 21 year old Lillian Payne disappeared from Rock Hill, SC. Her badly decomposed body was found stabbed to death on July 22, 2020 in the woods in Lowrys, SC less than six miles from Rex Heuermann’s property in Chester, SC.
On January 30 2022 Alexis Ware disappeared in Anderson, SC. Her car was found abandoned over an hour away in McCormick, SC in an area known for deer hunting activity. Ware’s family believes she was abducted.
On April 17, 2022 Maggie Stickler disappeared after leaving a hotel in Richmond, VA. Her skeletal remains were found 130 miles away in Elm City, NC in October 2022.
On May 16, 2022 the skull of a male was found on Mullinax Circle beside an ATV trail in Blacksburg, SC. The man was believed to have died 6 months to 1 year prior. Blacksburg, SC is 25 miles from Rex Heuermann’s property in Chester, SC.
On October 16, 2023 skeletal remains were found in a wooded area of Bragg Boulevard in Fayetteville, NC. Amanda Bagley was found murdered in the woods on Bragg Boulevard in 2000. In 1991 seven year old Jennifer Patterson vanished from Bragg Boulevard and was never seen again.
The two key geographical points to understand are Craig Heuermann’s home in China Grove, NC and Rex Heuermann’s property in Chester, SC.
Craig Heuermann’s Home in China Grove, NC
Rex Heuermann’s Property in Chester, SC
February 21 1990 Autumn Lee Cox Missing Concord, NC
Autumn Lee Cox disappeared 12 miles south of Craig Heuermann’s home in China Grove, NC
June 30 1990 Shelby J. Williams Murder Fayetteville, NC
July 18 1990 Madelyn Cox Thomas Missing Gastonia, NC
July 25 1990 Pamela Hoy Missing Burlington, NC Pamela Hoy disappeared after leaving her husbands home in Alamance and her van was found abandoned at a Days Inn in Greensboro where she lived
August 24 1990 Madelyn Cox Thomas Torso Murder Spartanburg, SC Madelyn Cox Thomas disappeared from Gastonia, NC and her dismembered torso was found in Spartanburg, SC
August 30 1990 Anna Caroline Lake Missing Duncan, SC
September 19 1990 Lisa Coburn Kesler Murder Hillsborough, NC Lisa Coburn Kesler was found murdered in Hillsborough, NC in 1990 and identified in 2023
September 27 1990 Diane Miller Marshall Murder Charlotte, NC
September 29 1990 Rex Heuermann Wedding New Brunswick, NJ
November 6 1990 Kathy Clark Fogleman Murder Liberty, NC *Arrest Keith Allen Brown*
November 7 1990 Pamela Mitchell Hoy Murder Liberty, NC Pamela Mitchell Hoy and Kathy Fogleman were found murdered one day apart and 500 feet away from each other. Pamela Hoy was wrapped in a quilt and bound with rope.
November 12 1990 Keith Allen Brown Arrest Graham, NC
November 22 1990 Hope Gibson Murder Hopkins, SC Hope Gibson was found murdered in a field Richland County, SC near where Silene Eaddy would be found murdered years later
December 5 1990 Dolly Ann Thomas-Caulder Missing Charlotte, NC
December 7 1990 Amy Gibson Missing Greensboro, NC
April 3 1991 Tina Marie Crouch Missing Gaffney, SC Tina Marie Crouch disappeared from Gaffney, SC about 30 miles northwest of Chester
June 23 1991 Jennifer Nicole Patterson Missing Spring Lake, NC Jennifer Patterson disappeared outside Fayetteville, NC
August 29 1991 Jane Doe Skull & Partial Skeletal Remains Murder Ridgeway, SC
February 1 1992 John Doe Murder Oak Ridge, NC
The John Doe in Oak Ridge was found approximately 5 miles from where Rex Heuermann’s mother’s boyfriend would later buy a home in 2001
March 1 1992 Rita Maxwell Missing Charlotte, NC Rita Maxwell lived on Dundeen Street in Charlotte. Her neighbor’s sister Judy Leggett would later disappear and was found murdered. Sherry Gaines was also found murdered in the woods by their house in ’95
March 25 1992 Debonne Dubose Missing Charlotte, NC
April 12 1992 Sherry Canup Mash Murder Salisbury, NC
Sherry Mash lived in Salisbury and worked in Landis near China Grove where Craig Heuermann lived in the 1990s Sherry Mash was found murdered 10 miles from where Craig Heuermann lived
June 8 1992 Norsaadah Husain Missing Clemson, SC
June 24 1992 Judy Carolyn Leggett Murder Charlotte, NC Judy Leggett disappeared after leaving her sister’s house on Dundeen Street. Judy Leggett’s sister was neighbors with murder victim Rita Maxwell Judy Leggett’s decomposing body was found in Charlotte, NC
July 5 1992 Autumn Lee Cox Murder Spartanburg, SC
Autumn Lee Cox was found murdered in Spartanburg, SC two years after she disappeared
September 11 1992 Katherine Prince Murder Mill Bridge, NC Katherine Price lived in Kannapolis, NC and was found murdered in Mill Bridge, NC. Katherine Prince was found murdered near the cruising spot Sloan Park Her body was found five miles from where Rex Heuermann’s brother Craig Heuermann lived in the 1990s
September 16 1992 Norsaadah Husain Murder Clemson, SC
September 22 1992 Denise Bernice Robinson Murder Greensboro, NC
January 2 1993 Anna Caroline Lake Murder Wellford, SC Anna Lake lived in Duncan and was found murdered in Wellford, SC Anna Lake, Autum Cox and Madelyn Cox Thomas all disappeared in 1990 and were found murdered in the Spartanburg, SC area
Spartanburg is approximately 50 miles west of Chester where Rex Heuermann now owns properties
February 2 1993 Parley Ann Pate Missing Raleigh, NC Parley Pate’s home was destroyed by a fire in 1986
March 27 1994 Shirley Ann McNair Missing St. Pauls, NC
June 24 1994 Kenya Latrice Lucas Murder Winston-Salem, NC
July 6 1994 Valerie Ann Rogers Murder Winston-Salem, NC
July 27 1994 Ruby Mae Commander Murder Raleigh, NC
August 17 1994 Beth-Ellen Vinson Missing Raleigh, NC Beth-Ellen Vinson worked for an escort agency and disappeared after meeting a client at 2:30 am in Raleigh, NC
August 23 1994 Beth-Ellen Vinson Murder Raleigh, NC
A Goldsboro newspaper received an anonymous letter claiming Beth-Ellen Vinson was murdered by a member of S&M group called the “Power Exchange of the Triangle”.
July 11 1995 Lois Jean Whaley Missing Salisbury, NC
Lois Jean Whaley disappeared from Salisbury only 8 miles north of where Craig Heuermann lived on in 1995
January 1 1996 Body Wrapped in Burlap Saluda River Newberry, SC
March 4 1996 Betty Lou Hamilton Missing Charlotte, NC
Betty Hamilton disappeared in Charlotte in March 1996
March 8 1996 Kathi Jean Warren Missing Charlotte, NC
March 22 1996 Patricia Horace Murder Charlotte, NC
April 13 1996 Rex Heuermann & Asa Ellerup Marriage
June 13 1996 Linda Lawrence Missing Rocky Mount, NC
June 22 1996 Antorya Newsome Missing Charlotte, NC
July 12 1996 Betty Lou Hamilton Murder Charlotte, NC Betty Lou Hamilton and Patricia Horace both disappeared in March 1996 and their bodies were found murdered at the same spot in Charlotte
July 18 1996 Jane Doe Skeletal Remains Charlotte, NC
September 5 1996 Antorya Newsome Murder Charlotte, NC
October 1996 Pamela Palmer Missing Raleigh, NC
December 11 1996 Sheila Patterson Manley Murder Blacksburg, SC
February 20 1997 Stacey Holsonback Murder Clemson, SC Stacey Holsonback’s murder shares similarities with the 1992 unsolved murder of another Clemson University student Norsaadah Husain
March 2 1997 Sheila Ann Bryant Murder Concord, NC Sheila Bryant lived and disappeared only 8 miles from Craig Heuermann’s home in China Grove, NC Sheila Bryant was found murdered in Concord 15 miles south of Craig Heuermann’s house in China Grove
March 19 1997 Paula Pressley Thomason Missing Greenville, SC
May 8 1997 Paula Pressley Thomason Murder Anderson, SC Paul Pressley Thomason was found murdered in Anderson, SC and wrapped in a shroud about 20 miles from where Stacey Holsonback was found murdered in February 1997
May 28 1997 Jane Doe Murder Skull South Point, NC
The woman’s skull was recovered 35 miles from Craig Heuermann’s house in China Grove, NC
June 1997 Rachel McArthur Murder Fayetteville, NC
June 7 1997 Amber Lundgren Murder Asheville, NC
Amber Lundgren disappeared from the same area of Asheville as Beverly Sherman did in 1987
Amber Lundgren was found murdered in the same location as Pamela Murray was in 1987
Amber Lundgren lived on Linden Ave in Asheville, NC. Her neighbor Garnetta Davis would soon be found murdered too
July 24 1997 Jane Doe Murder Lake Norman, Sherrill’s Ford, NC The nude body of an Asian woman was found with her hands and feet bound with rope in Lake Norman only 20 miles from Craig’s Heuermann’s home
August 7 1997 Garnetta Gail Davis Murder Asheville, NC Garnetta Gail Davis and Amber Lundgren were neighbors and were both were found murdered two months apart but cops dismissed the connection as a coincidence and never solved the murders
Garnetta Davis was found murdered in a lot along the French Broad River
August 26 1997 Craig Heuermann Recreational Drug Charge North Carolina
September 7 1997 Judy Smith Murder Asheville, NC
Judy Smith was murdered and her bones were found scattered in the woods in North Carolina nearly 600 miles away from where she disappeared in Philadelphia, PA
September 14 1997 Teresa Ann Johnson Murder Winston-Salem, NC
October 18 1997 Craig Heuermann Marriage Rowan County, NC
December 8 1997 Ernestine Howard Murder Winston-Salem, NC
November 22 1997 Janice Wessinger Murder Aiken, SC
January 7 1998 Brittany Locklear Murder Bowmore, NC Brittany Locklear was found murdered in Raeford near Fayetteville and Lumberton, NC
March 25 1998 Vicky Duncan Murder Rock Hill, SC Vicky Duncan was found murdered approximately 16 miles from Heuermann’s property in SC
June 16 1998 Sherry Carver Missing Seneca, SC
December 28 1998 Bobbie Jo Doster Johnson Murder Kannapolis, NC Bobbie Jo Doster Johnson was found strangled in the woods only 10 miles south of Craig Heuermann’s home
May 4 1999 Paula Merchant Missing Columbia, SC
July 4 1999 Brooke Leigh Henson Missing Travelers Rest, SC
September 20 1999 Samantha Parkes Murder Winston-Salem, NC
November 27 1999 Patricia Lapinskes Murder Fayetteville, NC
November 29 1999 Maurice Hauser Murder Winston-Salem, NC
Maurice Hauser was found murdered only two months after Samantha Parkes only 2.5 miles away. Both had been shot in the head, both had been arrested for sex work by cops in the past and both lived in Winston-Salem
February 14 2000 Asha Degree Missing Shelby, NC Asha Degree disappeared in Shelby, NC west of Charlotte. Her backpack was found wrapped in plastic in Morganton, NC. Rex Heuermann allegedly searched for the term “black girl 10 years old.” Asha Degree was nine years old.
March 7 2000 Amanda Bagley Murder Fayetteville, NC
Amanda Bagley was murdered in Fayetteville, NC
There were a number of similar murders in Fayetteville over the years
July 6 2000 Billie Jo Hughes Missing Peltzer, SC
July 11 2000 Craig Heuermann Ticket Mecklenburg County, Virginia
July 17 2000 Paula Minette Evans Missing Raleigh, NC
August 11 2000 Paula Minette Evans Murder Garner, NC
March 6 2001 Male Skeletal Remains Rock Hill, SC
May 2 2001 Daniel Duffy’s Son Purchases House Summerfield, NC
June 20 2001 Lillian Nance Missing Gastonia, NC
November 9 2001 Felicia Coleman Missing Goldsboro, NC Felicia Coleman disappeared from Goldsboro, NC
December 7 2001 Felicia Coleman Murder Wayne County, NC Cops made a number of incompetent errors investigating the murder of Felicia Coleman including taking 20 years to identify her after erroneously concluding her skull belonged to a man and then ruling Coleman out as a match for her own remains
December 21 2001 Female/Male(?) Skeletal Remains Namus #UP60643 Anderson, SC
Namus now lists the victims sex as male
July 24 2002 Deborah Jean Moore Missing Winston-Salem, NC
August 15 2002 Jennifer Short Missing + Michael Short & Mary Short Murder Bassett, VA Jennifer Short was abducted and her parents murdered in Bassett, VA. Rex Heuermann’s mother’s boyfriend’s son lived in Danville, VA about 30 miles away from Bassett for many years.
September 25 2002 Jennifer Short Murder Partial Skeletal Remains Stoneville, NC
Proximity between where the partial skeletal remains of nine year old Jennifer Short were found in Stoneville, NC, her home where her parents were murdered by gunshots to the head and where she was abducted from in Bassett, VA and Danville, VA where Rex Heuermann’s mother’s boyfriend’s son lived
December 5 2002 Dorothy Mae Hendricks Missing Wilson, NC
March 30 2003 Michelle Anne Driggers Murder Lumberton, NC Michelle Driggers was found murdered in Lumberton, NC
July 12 2003 Lisa Hardin Murder Lumberton, NC
Lisa Harden was found murdered in Lumberton near where three other women were found murdered and two women disappeared all in 2017
Lisa Hardin was found murdered approximately 1.5miles from Michelle Driggers
July 18 2003 Robert Wayne Connor Missing Claremont, NC
July 21 2003 Stephanie Paige Haynes Missing Charlotte, NC Stephanie Haynes disappeared on July 21, 2003 in Charlotte and was never seen again. Long Island Serial Killer victim Jessica Taylor’s torso was discovered in Manorville, NY on July 26, 2003.
September 14 2003 Katherine Alice Moody Missing Kannapolis, NC Katherine Moody disappeared in Kannapolis, NC ten miles from Craig Heuermann’s house in China Grove, NC
October 19 2003 Katherine Alice Moody Murder Kannapolis, NC
Katherine Moody was found murdered 10 miles from Craig Heuermann’s home
November 22 2003 John Doe #1 & John Doe #2 Skeletal Remains Dalzell, SC
November 22 2003 John Doe #UP2237 Skeletal Remains Red Springs, NC
March 3 2004 Betsy Dickens Murder Hickory, NC
April 1 2004 Jessica Fallon Hooks Missing Charlotte, NC
April 9 2004 Cynthia Lail Murder Hickory, NC
April 13 2004 Lila Mae Martin Missing Greenville, SC
April 17 2004 Silene Eaddy Murder Hopkins, SC
Silene Eaddy was found murdered near where Hope Gibson was found in the woods in 1990
October 2 2004 Unidentified Female Skull Pembroke, NC
October 11 2004 Skeletal Remains Charlotte, NC
October 12 2004 Stephanie Lewis Missing Lumberton, NC
January 24 2005 Crystal Gail Soles Missing Andrews, SC
April 19 2005 Amanda Dell Pike Murder Asheville, NC
May 26 2005 Craig Heuermann Noise Ticket Chester, SC
September 6 2005 Joy Winters Missing Goldsboro, NC October 29 2005 Sherri Puzjak Missing Orangeburg, SC
December 20 2005 Jessica Michelle Lowrey Missing Lumberton, NC
July 31 2006 Kelly Lane Smith Murder Asheville, NC
Kelly Smith’s partial dismembered remains were found in two locations in Asheville, NC
August 4 2006 Christi Hanks Missing Anderson, SC
Christi Hanks lived in Anderson approximately 2 miles from where Paula Thomason was found murdered in 1997
December 14 2006 Christi Hanks Murder Belton, SC Christi Hanks’ skeletal remains were found bound and gagged with duct tape in a field in Anderson County, SC
June 10 2007 Angela Nobles Rothen Missing Hanover County, NC
June 27 2007 Terri Blue Missing Fayetteville, NC
November 9 2007 Kyle Fleischmann Missing Charlotte, NC
September 27 2008 Jane Doe Murder Skeletal Remains St Matthews, SC
August 9 2009 Stacy Lester Missing Sumter, SC
Sumter where Stacy Lester disappeared is 75 miles southeast of Chester, SC
March 1 2010 Lillian Mae Mathis Missing Columbia, SC
April 10 2010 Jahela Lucero-Menor Murder Julian, NC
Jahela Lucero-Menor lived in Greensboro, NC ten miles south of Rex Heuermann’s mother’s boyfriend’s son
Jahela Lucero-Menor was found murdered in the same area as Kathy Fogleman and Pamela Hoy were in 1990
March 17 2011 Jane Doe Murder Charlotte, NC
April 11 2011 April Pickens Missing Asheville, NC
September 3 2011 Adriana Laster Missing Elgin, SC Adriana Laster was found murdered in Elgin, SC approximately 30 miles east of Rex Heuermann’s property in Chester, SC
October 26 2011 Jane Doe Murder Startex, SC The skeletal remains of a woman were found under a tarp hidden underneath a couch in the woods in Startex, SC. The woman was found approximately one mile from where Anna Caroline Lake’s skeletal remains were found in 1993 There are a number of similar unsolved murders around Startex and the Spartanburg area
January 23 2012 Ashley Lynn Garino Missing Goldsboro, NC
April 8 2012 Shalonda Harts Missing Columbia, SC
August 23 2012 Crystal Dawn Morrison Missing Concord, NC
June 14 2013 Amy Bridgeman Missing Weldon, NC
November 22 2013 Jameika Sabb Missing Charlotte. NC
Charlotte where Jameika Stabb disappeared is the closest big city to Chester, SC and Craig Heuermann lived north of Charlotte in China Grove in the 90s
March 11 2014 John Doe Greensboro, NC Skeletal remains were discovered in Greensboro near where Jahela Lucero-Menor lived in 2010 when she was murdered
November 25 2014 Aaliyah Bell Missing Rock Hill, SC
Aaliyah Bell disappeared only 17 miles from Rex Heuermann’s property in Chester, SC
March 15 2015 Brian Kelly Clontz Murder Julian, NC Brian Kelly Clontz was found murdered in the same area as Kathy Fogleman, Pamela Hoy and Jahela Menor
September 2 2015 Rose Martinez Missing Gastonia, NC
January 7 2016 Tyarra Williams Missing Goldsboro, NC Tyarra Williams disappeared in Greensboro where Rex Heuermann’s mother’s boyfriend died in 2018
July 22 2016 Khunh Siu Murder Greensboro, NC
August 28 2016 Carmen Marie Gonzalez-Pinto Missing Charlotte, NC
October 15 2016 Ketie Jones Murder Charlotte, NC
October 22 2016 Melissa “Missy” Poitra Murder Durham NC
November 23 2016 Rhonda Kelley Missing Greenwood, SC In 2013 cops arrested and charged Rhona Kelley with a crime after accusing her of receiving $10 dollars in exchange for sex Rhona Kelley disappeared approximately 70 miles southwest of Chester, SC where Rex Heuermann owns property
November 30 2016 Sherrell Faulkner Murder Charlotte, NC
March 29 2017 John Doe Wrapped in Plastic Mount Airy, NC
April 18 2017 Christina Bennett & Rhonda Lynn Jones Lumberton, NC
Christina Bennett and Rhonda Jones were found hidden on abandoned properties similar to the possible LISK murders in Brooklyn
May 31 2017 Julia Bean Missing Sumter, SC
Julia Bean disappeared in Sumpter, SC
June 3 2017 Megan Oxendine Murder Lumberton, NC Megan Oxendine was found murdered in the weeds of an abandoned house a block from Christina Bennett and Rhonda Jones after going on the news about the Lumberton murders.
July 13 2017 Carolyn Allen Missing Charlotte, NC
July 27 2017 Cynthia Jacobs Missing Lumberton, NC
September 5 2017 Abby Patterson Missing Lumberton, NC Abby Patterson disappeared after getting into a brown Buick in Lumberton just a few blocks from the bodies where the bodies of three women were found She disappeared only a few blocks from where Cynthia Jacobs disappeared two months earlier
February 4 2018 Margaret Ann Holcomb Missing Conway, SC
May 2 2018 Daniel Duffy Death Rex Heuermann’s Mother’s Boyfriend Greensboro, NC
July 8 2018 Rita Maynor Body Found Lumberton, NC Rita Maynor was found in Lumberton near where three murder women were found murdered and two more disappeared in 2017
August 31 2018 Craig Heuermann Ticket Albemarle County, VA
September 27 2018 Lisa Allen Murder Greenville, SC
Lisa Allen was found wrapped in a blanket in Greenville, SC
October 18 2018 Andrea Gail Morgan Missing High Point, NC Andrea Morgan disappeared in October 2018 in High Point outside Greensboro where Rex Heuermann’s mother’s boyfriend died in 2018
January 2 2019 Laura Anders Missing Mountain Rest, SC
February 4 2019 Erlin Noemi Padilla Valenzuela Missing Greensville, SC
Valenzuela disappeared near where Lisa Allen was found wrapped in a blanket in September 2018
Valenzuela disappeared a few blocks from where Lila Martin disappeared in 2004
November 21 2019 Tabitha Goins Missing South Hope Mills, NC Tabitha Goins disappeared from South Hope Mills between Fayetteville and Lumberton where a serial killer is believed to have been committing murders
December 6 2019 Tammy Stubblefield Missing Walhalla, SC
December 9 2019 Crystal Dawn Morrison Murder Concord, NC Crystal Morrison disappeared in August 2012 and her skeletal remains were found in Concord, NC 11 miles south of where Craig Heuermann lived
May 13 2020 Lillian Marie Payne Missing Rock Hill, SC Lillian Payne disappeared in Rock Hill, SC about 15 miles from Rex Heuermann’s property in Chester, SC
July 22 2020 Lillian Marie Payne Murder Lowrys, SC Lillian Payne was found murdered less than six miles from Rex Heuermann’s property in Chester, SC
November 28 2020 Renee Rowland King Missing Westminster, SC
December 15 2020 Flavie Alix Marie Cocard Missing Abbeville, SC
February 8 2021 Renee Rowland King Murder Westminster, SC
A Wilson County Sheriff’s Deputy strings crime scene tape near the site along Four Tenths Road in Wilson County where skeletal remains of a woman were found in October. Drew C. Wilson | TimesCpl. R Diaz, left, and Senior Deputy J. Doss with the Wilson County Sheriff’s Office walk along a farm path away from the scene where two deer hunters found human remains Saturday afternoon. Drew C. Wilson | Times
April 1 2023 Amanda Karraker Missing Rock Hill, SC
May 5 2023 Amanda Karraker Body Found Rock Hill, SC
October 11 2023 Skeletal Remains Fayetteville, NC
Skeletal remains were found hidden in the attic of a former restaurant on Bragg Boulevard in Fayetteville, NC
October 16 2023 Skeletal Remains Fayetteville, NC Skeletal remains were found in the woods in Fayetteville, NC near where Amanda Bagley’s body was discovered in 2000.
Murder, Inc. Exclusive: Was the Long Island Serial Killer murdering in Virginia?
Alicia Showalter Reynolds disappeared on March 2, 1996 while driving from Baltimore, MD to Charlottesville, VA. Her abandoned automobile was found parked along the side of Route 29 in Culpeper, VA. A white man in a dark truck was seen appearing to assist Reynolds with her car. Her body was found about 30 yards off Va. 751 near a logging area in rural Lignum, VA on May 7, 1996. It’s suspected her killer was the white man with the dark truck who was also reportedly flagging down other women and telling them there was something wrong with their car. The man was described as “tall” and in some accounts 5’10 – 6′ tall. This killer is known as the Route 29 Stalker.
On July 14, 1996 74 year old church organist Thelma Scroggins was shot to death inside her home in Lignum, VA near where Alicia Showalter Reynolds body was discovered. Her purse and pickup truck were missing. Police framed three kids for the murder.
On July 28, 1996 Alisha Johnson, 19, disappeared while walking to the store to buy hair gel in Alexandria, VA. About a week and a half later on August 6, 1996, a man in Marshall, VA found a human leg on his property. He then discovered another limb nearby. Police searched the woods and a small pond in the area. The remains were later identified as the severed legs of Alisha Johnson. The rest of her body parts appear to have never been recovered.
On September 18, 1996 Anne Carolyn McDaniel, 20, disappeared from a group home for people with disabilities in Orange, VA. McDaniel had told fellow residents she was going on a date. A blue Honda was seen driving up and down the street at the President Madison Inn group home where she lived. Her burned body was found by hunters in rural Batna next to Lignum, five miles from where Alicia Showalter Reynolds’ remains were found. McDaniel’s body was found covered by brush that was lit on fire about 70 feet from the road and 50 yards from a hunting cabin in the woods.
On March 1, 1999 two hikers walking on a footbridge in Richmond, VA discovered the severed head of a man. The man’s headless and handless torso was found in the St. James River about a mile away. He was identified as Henry Edward Northington, a 6’4, 39 year old gay Navy vet who lived nearby in a homeless camp. The footbridge where Northington’s severed head was found leads to a popular cruising spot.
On June 15, 1999 Kimberly Dawn Alexander disappeared from a Wendy’s fast food restaurant where she worked in Winchester, VA. Her car was found abandoned approximately 9 miles away in a parking lot. Her body was found in a remote wooded area of Jefferson County, West Virginia.
On November 22, 2000 Brenda Gee-Knight was last seen after her sister dropped her off near the Satellite restaurant in Richmond, VA. This was three days after Long Island Serial Killer victim Valerie Mack’s torso was discovered in Manorville, NY. On June 29, 2001 skeletal remains were discovered along the Mattaponi River by a canoeist in rural King and Queen County north of Richmond. Years later the remains were determined to belong to Brenda Gee-Knight. The victim is believed to have been involved with sex work at the time of her disappearance. Her murder remains unsolved by police.
On October 3, 2002 Carrie Ann Williams disappeared after leaving her shift at Hooters. Her body was discovered next to a dumpster in Richmond, VA. She’d been shot in the head and wrapped in plastic. Her body was bruised and bore indications she was bound and tortured before her murder. Her boyfriend was charged with her murder and acquitted.
On November 27, 2003 the dismembered torso of a woman was discovered by a deer hunter in the woods of Winchester, VA. The torso is reported to have been there for at least several days. The woman is believed to have been of Southeast Asian descent and likely aged 25 to 50. She has never been identified and her missing body parts never found.
December 18, 2005 Sheryl Warner was murdered in her home in Culpeper, VA. She was on the phone when a man knocked on her door and said he was having car trouble and asked to use her phone. Sheryl Warner was later found in the basement bound, shot in the head, and hanging from the ceiling by an electrical cord. Her home was also set on fire. Sheryl Warner’s house on Route 29 is across the street from where Alicia Showalter Reynolds’ car was found in 1996.
On May 14, 2007 partial human remains of a woman were discovered along the water at Lieutenant Run behind a Ramada Inn in Petersburg, VA. The woman’s skull was found in 2012 approximately two miles away but she remains unidentified.
On November 16, 2007, the partial skeletal remains of a man and a woman were discovered in a yard on Tranquility Lane in Sutherland, VA. The woman was identified as Shirleetha Ann Daniel but the man apparently remains unidentified.
On September 13, 2010 Samantha Clarke disappeared from Orange, VA. She lived across the field behind the group home where Anne McDaniel lived and was last seen in 1996. Samantha Clarke disappeared 11 days after Long Island Serial Killer victim Amber Costello. Police suspect she was murdered by Randy Taylor, who was convicted of murdering Alexis Murphy and, according to police, contacted Samantha Clarke before she disappeared.
On April 8, 2011 Robert Hourihan disappeared from Palmyra, Virginia. The 33 year old vanished leaving a young daughter and a wife of 13 years who believes he was murdered. Hourihan has a heart condition that requires daily medication. He left his medication and never refilled his prescription. His car was found abandoned at a Target in La Plata, Maryland over 100 miles away. Robert Hourihan didn’t know anyone who lived in Maryland. He’s never been seen again.
On July 7, 2014, 49 year old Janet Renee Field disappeared from her home in Scottsville, VA. Her house was seven miles south of Rex Heuermann’s mother’s home. Her car was found abandoned at a park and ride in Zion Crossroad, VA, seven miles north of Rex Heuermann’s mother’s home. Field’s purse and keys were located inside her car. Police suspect foul play in her disappearance.
On June 17, 2017 Emma Compton Layne disappeared in Cody, VA. Two hunters found her remains in the woods on November 22, 2017. Her cause of death was traumatic neck injury.
Rex Heuermann’s mother lived in Palmyra, VA from approximately 1994-2019. In an April 2018 deposition, Heuermann described traveling “at least half a dozen times” to Virginia in the past year. How frequently did Rex Heuermann travel to Virginia in the 1990s and 2000s? Law enforcement alleges Rex Heuermann killed while his family was away, but what about while Heuermann was away from his family? Rex Heuermann acknowledges traveling to Virginia with and without his wife, but claims he can’t remember if his wife was with him on the trip around March 2018. What happened on that trip?
What do Rex Heuermann’s cellphone records indicate for September 2010 when Samantha Clarke disappeared? Was he in Virginia at the time of her disappearance? What about April 8, 2011 when Robert Hourihan disappeared or July 7, 2014 when Janet Field vanished near Palmyra?
Just how far back do Rex Heuermann’s ties to Virginia go?
On April 17, 2022 Maggie Stickler was last seen around the motels at Chamberlayne Avenue and Brookland Park Boulevard in Richmond, VA. Two hunters discovered her skeletal remains on October 15, 2022 over 150 miles away in a wooded area of Elm City, North Carolina.
Rex Heuermann’s Mother’s Home 18 Zephyr Road Palmyra, VA (1994-2019)
March 2 1996 Alicia Showalter Reynolds Missing Culpeper, VA Alicia Showalter Reynolds’ car was found abandoned on Route 29 in Culpeper, VA about 40 miles north of Rex Heuermann’s mother’s house in Palmyra, VA
A woman named Sheryl Warner who lived across Route 29 from where Alicia Reynolds’ car was found was murdered in her home in 2005. She was on the phone when she answered the door and spoke to a man who was claimed he was having car trouble.
May 7 1996 Alicia Showalter Reynolds Murder Lignum, VA Alicia Reynolds body was found in rural Lignum, VA. More bodies would be discovered there in the next few months. Lignum is about 40 miles north of Palmyra
June 1 1996 Lollie Winans & Julianne Williams Murder Shenandoah National Park, VA Lollie Winans & Julie Williams were found murdered and bound with duct tape at their camp site in Shenandoah National Park northwest of Culpeper, VA.
July 14 1996 Thelma Scroggins Murder Lignum, VA
Thelma Scroggins was murdered near where Alicia Showalter Reynolds’ found just two months earlier
July 26 1996 Alisa Johnson Missing Alexandria, VA
August 4 1996 Alisa Johnson Murder Severed Legs Found Marshall, VA Alisha Johnson disappeared from Alexandria in July 1996. Her severed legs were discovered over 40 miles away in rural Marshall
September 18 1996 Anne Carolyn McDaniel Missing Orange, VA
Anne McDaniel was found in Batna, VA near Lignum where Alicia Reynolds was found a few months earlier. Both victims were found dumped similar distances from remote service or dirt roads. Brush or sticks was found on top of McDaniel and Reynolds remains.
September 15 1997 Anne Carver Clapp Missing Charlottesville, VA
March 1 1999 Henry Edward Northington Torso Murder Richmond, VA
June 12 1999 Kimberly Dawn Alexander Murder Winchester, VA
November 22 2000 Brenda Gee-Knight Missing Richmond, VA
June 29 2001 Brenda Gee-Knight Murder King and Queen County, VA
January 12 2001 Anne Carver Clapp Murder Bones Found Columbia, VA
Anne Carver Clapp lived in Palmyra one mile from Rex Heuermann’s mother
Anne Clapp’s remains were found in Columbia southeast of Palmyra
October 3 2002 Carrie Ann Williams Murder Richmond, VA
January 2 2003 Onnie Donnell Taylor Torso Murder Lawrenceville, VA
August 14 2003 Joan Weigelhofer Murder Gum Spring, VA
November 27 2003 Jane Doe Torso Murder Winchester, VA
October 11 2004 Linda Mae Archer Missing Woodbridge, VA
December 2005 Sheryl Warner Murder Culpeper, VA
Sheryl Warner was found murdered in her home extremely close to where Alicia Showalter Reynolds’ car was found abandoned in Culpeper, VA. In both murders the killer is believed to have used a ruse of car trouble to trick the victims.
May 14 2007 Jane Doe Murder Petersburg, VA
November 16 2007 Shirleetha Ann Daniel & John Doe(Error?) Murder Sutherland, VA
May 14 2010 Linda Mae Archer Murder Woodbridge, VA
September 13 2010 Samantha Clarke Missing Orange, VA Samantha Clarke and Anne McDaniel lived and disappeared under 1,000 feet from each other
March 23 2011 Erica Dawn Maynor Murder Woodbridge, VA
April 8 2011 Robert Lee Hourihan Missing Palmyra, VA Robert Lee Hourihan disappeared from Palmyra, VA where Rex Heuermann’s mother lived
August 12 2012 Jane Doe Skull Found Petersburg, VA
September 20 2012 Body Parts Found Packaged in Black Garbage Bags Manassas, VA
November 20 2012 Sage Smith Missing Charlottesville, VA Sage Smith disappeared about 12 miles from Heuermann’s Virginia home
July 2 2014 Janet Renee Field Missing Scottsville, VA
Janet Field disappeared from Scottsville, VA near where Rex Heuermann’s mother lived
June 17 2017 Emma Compton Layne Murder Halifax, VA
April 2018 Rex Heuermann Deposition
April 17 2022 Maggie Stickler Missing Richmond, VA
October 15 2022 Maggie Stickler Murder Elm City, NC
A Wilson County Sheriff’s Deputy strings crime scene tape near the site along Four Tenths Road in Wilson County where skeletal remains of a woman were found in October. Drew C. Wilson | Times
Cpl. R Diaz, left, and Senior Deputy J. Doss with the Wilson County Sheriff’s Office walk along a farm path away from the scene where two deer hunters found human remains Saturday afternoon. Drew C. Wilson | Times
Maggie Stickler disappeared from Richmond, VA but her skeletal remains were found over 150 miles away in North Carolina. Long Island Serial Killer suspect Rex Heuermann owns property in South Carolina. Did Rex Heuermann take any trips in 2022? Just how close of a tail did law enforcement keep on Rex Heuermann once he was identified as a suspect in March 2022?
Murder, Inc. Exclusive: Was a man found bound and murdered in the Bellmore Chanel in 2002 a victim of the Long Island Serial Killer?
On September 25, 2002 boaters spotted the body of a man floating in the Bellmore Channel west of the Goose Creek Bridge that connects Wantagh Parkway to Jones Beach. Police said the man was believed to be of Asian descent, approximately 5’7, very thin and was found wearing only underwear. The man’s hands were bound behind his back and his feet were also bound with an undisclosed material. A binding of similar material was also found around the victim’s neck. A cinder block was fastened to the man’s body. As of January 2003, the man’s identity was unknown. It’s unclear if police ever identified the victim. He is not listed in the Namus system for the unidentified in Nassau County.
It’s unclear when the “Asian Male” found at Gilgo in 2011 was murdered. His murder is suspected to predate the Gilgo 4 victims, which would be prior to 2007. If the “Asian Male” was murdered before Maureen Brainard-Barnes, “Asian Male” may be the earliest victim of the ten found in 2010 and 2011 whose whole body was dumped on Ocean Parkway (excluding Peaches’ child). It’s possible the Long Island Serial Killer was not as comfortable dumping non-dismembered bodies at Ocean Parkway prior to the “Asian Male”.
September 25 2002 Asian Male Bellmore Channel Jones Beach, NY
According to police, Rex Heuermann searched for the term “asian twink tied up porn”
Long Island Serial Killer victims Maureen Brainard-Barnes, Megan Waterman, Melissa Barthelemy and Amber Costello were all found bound around the feet, arms/hands and head area in a similar manner to Bellmore Channel Asian Male.
The cops and G-Men had “the box” of the few blocks where Rex Heuermann and William Hughes lived in Massapequa Park by 2012, meaning all they had to do was drive around the block to see Rex Heuermann’s Chevy Avalanche parked out front.
The National 9 Inn on Stockton Boulevard in Sacramento where Tiffany Mason was last seen getting into the car of a man is less than a mile from the location of the May 28, 1977 East Area Rapist crime.
After the discovery of the body, 
Early that year on 
On May 27, 2002 jack sprat discussed the topic of A
The house on Smith Street where Suzanne Goldfarb was found murdered is 6 miles west of Rex Heuermann’s home in Massapequa Park, NY.
A user with the same username of nyhotcpl posted numerous swinger ads on a number of different hookup sites. nyhotcpl is about as common of a username as andy roberts and Murder, Inc. is unable to determine if any are the same poster from the nyhotcpl Internationalsexguide Bangkok post.
Kenneth Heuermann was part of the Luther League Youth Group as a boy growing up on Long Island.
Witness described a black and/or blue 1959 or 1960 sedan seen near the crime scene.
DNA was recovered from the Annie Rippel Lee crime scene that can be compared to Rex Heuermann. G-Men and cops, please do so immediately 
On October 10, 1992 kids found Cindy Thiele’s skeletal remains in the brush and trees along Lake Ontario State Parkway in Hamlin, NY. Thiele’s skeletal remains were the third set of remains located at the Rochester Serial Killer’s Lake Ontario State Parkway cluster site. Cindy Thiele had disappeared from Rochester in July 1992.
On December 7 1991 Victoria Jobson was found murdered and left in a vacant lot in Rochester, NY. She’d been stabbed to death and is considered the 15th victim of the Rochester Serial Killer. 
Annie Rippel was found murdered and bound with duct tape in Little Tonawanda Creek in Alexander, NY. Rex Heuermann’s uncle lived 8 miles staright east on Creek Rd in Pavilion, NY
Keisha Roman was found murdered at a fishing boat launch on the Susquehanna River in Pennsylvania just 20 miles south of Rex Heuermann’s sister’s house in Chenango Forks, NY
Brian Heyden’s body was discovered hidden in the woods in Portland, NY in 2018 not far from where Marquita Mull and Jane Doe were discovered in 2021
Steven Arnold lives only half a mile from Long Island Serial Killer suspect Rex Heuermann. Has Arnold been excluded as a contributor to the mitochondrial DNA recovered from the LISK victims? Do Rex Heuermann and Steven Arnold know each other? 
Pamela Mitchell Hoy and Kathy Fogleman were found murdered one day apart and 500 feet away from each other. Pamela Hoy was wrapped in a quilt and bound with rope.
Beth-Ellen Vinson worked for an escort agency and disappeared after meeting a client at 2:30 am in Raleigh, NC
Betty Lou Hamilton and Patricia Horace both disappeared in March 1996 and their bodies were found murdered at the same spot in Charlotte
Rex Heuermann allegedly searched for the term “black girl 10 years old.” Asha Degree was nine years old.
Jennifer Short was abducted and her parents murdered in Bassett, VA. Rex Heuermann’s mother’s boyfriend’s son lived in Danville, VA about 30 miles away from Bassett for many years.
Katherine Moody disappeared in Kannapolis, NC ten miles from Craig Heuermann’s house in China Grove, NC
The skeletal remains of a woman were found under a tarp hidden underneath a couch in the woods in Startex, SC. The woman was found approximately one mile from where Anna Caroline Lake’s skeletal remains were found in 1993
Skeletal remains were discovered in Greensboro near where Jahela Lucero-Menor lived in 2010 when she was murdered
Megan Oxendine was found murdered in the weeds of an abandoned house a block from Christina Bennett and Rhonda Jones after going on the news about the Lumberton murders.
Abby Patterson disappeared after getting into a brown Buick in Lumberton just a few blocks from the bodies where the bodies of three women were found
She disappeared only a few blocks from where Cynthia Jacobs disappeared two months earlier
The Jane Doe in Rural Hall, NC were found 8 miles from the home of Rex Heuermann’s mother’s boyfriend’s son.
Lillian Payne was found murdered less than six miles from Rex Heuermann’s property in Chester, SC
Alicia Showalter Reynolds’ car was found abandoned on Route 29 in Culpeper, VA about 40 miles north of Rex Heuermann’s mother’s house in Palmyra, VA
Sage Smith disappeared about 12 miles from Heuermann’s Virginia home
Maggie Stickler disappeared from Richmond, VA but her skeletal remains were found over 150 miles away in North Carolina. Long Island Serial Killer suspect Rex Heuermann owns property in South Carolina. Did Rex Heuermann take any trips in 2022? Just how close of a tail did law enforcement keep on Rex Heuermann once he was identified as a suspect in March 2022? 
Murder, Inc. 
